Comment on Is Determinism A Special Case Of Randomness?

Tue, 05 May 2015 22:46:06 GMT

My question was not rhetorical. But it was unclear. Water indeed doesn't feel, as far as we know.

What would it feel like FOR YOU to not have free will?

Would irresistible voices in your head telling you what to do give you that feeling? Would observing your arm flailing about without your input? Would watching yourself reach for your X-Box despite knowing that you should study for a test? Or knowing that someone else can predict your actions and maybe even thoughts before you aware of having them?

Think about all these very different no-free-will cases and tell me what not having free will means for you. Not for water.

Discuss