gjm comments on Deliberate Grad School - Less Wrong

22 Post author: Academian 04 October 2015 10:11AM

You are viewing a comment permalink. View the original post to see all comments and the full post content.

Comments (153)

You are viewing a single comment's thread. Show more comments above.

Comment author: EHeller 08 October 2015 03:48:42AM 4 points [-]

How hard your quals are depends on how well you know your field. I went to a top 5 physics program, and everyone passed their qualifying exams, roughly half of whom opted to take the qual their first year of grad school. Obviously, we weren't randomly selected though.

Fellowships are a crapshoot that depend on a lot of factors outside your control, but getting funding is generally pretty easy in the sciences. When you work as an "RA" you are basically just doing your thesis research. TAing can be time consuming, but literally no one cares if you do it poorly, so it's not high pressure.

But this is a red flag:

Let’s assume you have the financial aspect of your PhD taken care of (e.g. You have an easy/enjoyable TA job). What other requirements are there other than passing Quals? Could I read interesting books indefinitely until I find something interesting to publish?

That isn't how research works, at least in the sciences. Research is generally 1% "big idea" and 99% slowly grinding it out to see if it works. Your adviser, if he/she is any good, will help you find a big idea that you can make some progress on and you'll be grinding it out every week and meeting with your adviser or other collaborators if you've gotten stuck.

That said, a bad adviser probably won't pay any attention to you. So you can do whatever you want for about 7 years until people realize you've made no progress and the wheels come off the bus (at which point they'll probably hand you a masters degree and send you on your way).

Comment author: gjm 12 October 2015 11:24:36AM 4 points [-]

literally no one cares if you do [TAing] poorly

I have heard rumours that students are actually people, and that they care about the quality of the teaching they receive.

Comment author: EHeller 12 October 2015 07:04:35PM 3 points [-]

You'd think so, but office hours and TA sections without attendance grades are very sparsely attended.

Comment author: anna_macdonald 17 October 2015 02:08:52AM 2 points [-]

When I was in college, I almost never went to office hours or TA hours... except for one particular class, where the professor was a probably-brilliant guy who was completely incapable of giving a straight explanation or answer to anything. TA hours were packed full; most of the class went, and the TA explained all the stuff the teacher hadn't.

Comment author: IlyaShpitser 14 October 2015 04:45:59PM 2 points [-]

Not in my class.