Enough skill in oratory (or something closely related) gets you unboxed. The question is how plausible it is that a superintelligent AI would have enough. (A related question is whether there's such a thing as enough. There might not be, just as there's no such thing as enough kinetic energy to let you escape from inside a black hole's horizon, but the reported results of AI-Box games[1] suggest -- though they certainly don't prove -- that there is.)

[1] The term "experiments" seems a little too highfalutin'.

[EDITED to add: I take it Houshalter is saying that Hitler's known oratorical skills aren't enough to convince him that H. would have won an AI-Box game, playing as the AI. I am inclined to agree. Hitler was very good at stirring up a crowd, but it's not clear how that generalizes to persuading an intelligent and skeptical individual.]

Well for one, the human isn't in a box trying to get out. So an AI mimicking a human isn't going to say weird things like "let me out of this box!" This method is equivalent to writing Hitler a letter asking him a question, and him sending you an answer. That doesn't seem dangerous at all.

Second, I really don't believe Hitler could escape from a box. The AI box experiments suggest a human can do it, but the scenario is very different than a real AI box situation. E.g. no back and forth with the gatekeeper, and the gatekeeper doesn't have to sit there for 2 hours and listen to the AI emotionally abuse him. If Hitler says something mean, the gatekeeper can just turn him off or walk away.