Gordon_Rae comments on Three Fallacies of Teleology - Less Wrong

21 Post author: Eliezer_Yudkowsky 25 August 2008 10:27PM

You are viewing a comment permalink. View the original post to see all comments and the full post content.

Comments (16)

Sort By: Old

You are viewing a single comment's thread.

Comment author: Gordon_Rae 02 September 2008 09:56:28AM -2 points [-]

This article seems to be a redescription of phenomena, so that you don't need to draw a causal arrow going from the future to the past. An alternative methodology would be to draw the arrow anyway, and discuss what it means; and have your imagined interlocutors explain why their methodology forbids drawing the arrow. (Perhaps Aristotle was wiser than Bayes.)

It seems to me you've redescribed Aristotle to make him consistent with C20th folk psychology, where intelligence is inside people's heads (and not anywhere else), rather than considering alternative ways of modelling a distributed intelligence implemented as a network of multiple agents.

It's worth being more explicit about why you describe Mary differently from Mary's teeth. Mary is modelled as an autonomous agent, whose actions are directed by intelligence inside her. Her teeth are modelled as responding to intelligence located outside them: by Mary's choosing to bite and chew, and by an evolutionary process selecting who survives.