Tim_Tyler comments on Recursive Self-Improvement - Less Wrong
You are viewing a comment permalink. View the original post to see all comments and the full post content.
You are viewing a comment permalink. View the original post to see all comments and the full post content.
Comments (54)
Sexual selection is at the root of practically all the explanations for the origin of our large brains. To quote from Sue Blackmore:
The idea that intelligence can play an important role in evolutionary change arises from the observation that intelligent agents are doing the selecting - in sexual selection. They get to use induction, deduction, analogies, prediction - the whole toolkit of intelligence - and the results are then reflected in the germ line of the next generation. Any idea that the loop between intelligence and brain design information has only closed recently - or has yet to close - is simply wrong. Human brains have been influencing human brain evolution for millions of years - in the same way that they have been influencing dog evolution for millions of years - by acting as the selective agent.
Brains don't just choose. They also create circumstances where there is a lot of information on which to make choices. The mating dance brainy-females often lead males on exposes their parasite load - and so their genetic quality - to selection. So: brains do not just select - they actively create opportunties for selection by intelligence to have a large influence.
If you look at female secondary sex charateristics, they are the products of mind, written back onto the body by evolution. Breasts, red lips - and so on are physical projections of mental analogy-making equipment.
Of course the other classic example of the mental turning into the genetic is the Baldwin effect - where learned, acquired characteristics find their way out of the minds in which they arose and back into the gene pool.
Evolution is no stranger to the action of intelligence - indeed, without millions of intelligent choices by our ancestors, the human race as we know it today would not exist.