LESSWRONG
LW

Comment Permalink
Answer by lexande50

Since apparently some confirmed cases never develop symptoms (this study of Diamond Princess passengers estimates 18%), it seems the answer to your second question is "never"?

Reply
Raemon20

Sorry, I worded that wrong. Edited the OP.

Reply
See in context
by Raemon
1 min read
A
38

28

A key question for people figuring out good longterm isolation practices is "how long do I have to be symptom-free before I'm 'certified safe'?"

This post on the typical-course-of-COVID-19 provides some studies that inform on the question, but doesn't directly answer it yet.

I recall hearing something like "most cases last less than two weeks", but I'm not sure if two weeks is actually a strong enough upper bound that I'd feel comfortable encouraging lots of people to act on it.

This contains two subquestions:

  • If you get sick with COVID-19, during what period will you be contagious?
  • If you are isolated, and don't appear to have symptoms, how long before you can be confident that you are not a carrier?

(I'm personally most interested in the answer to the second question right now, but both seem important)

Covid-19
Frontpage

28

How long should someone quarantine to be sure they aren't contagious with Covid?
New Answer
New Comment

3 Answers sorted by
top scoring

Elizabeth

*

160

I looked into the success of different countries' quarantines. New Zealand had both the best implementation and the best data, so I draw most of my conclusions from them. With a 14 day quarantine (testing on day 3 and 12), New Zealand had a "barely visible on the graph" number of import-adjacent infections. But according to a statistical model, these are caused by infections caught during quarantine (i.e. a couple with one infected member quarantines together, the second member catches it on day 7,  leaves after an effective quarantine of only 7 days, then spreads it in the wild), so if people are completely isolated and occasionally tested, 14 days in indeed sufficient

 

 

lexande

50

Since apparently some confirmed cases never develop symptoms (this study of Diamond Princess passengers estimates 18%), it seems the answer to your second question is "never"?

[-]Raemon20

Sorry, I worded that wrong. Edited the OP.

Reply

waveman

10

Worth pointing out that if we quarantine for X days and do not actually test, relying on symptoms, then we are selecting for slow incubation and/or mild/no symptoms before X days.

1 Related Questions

Parent Question
4 comments, sorted by
top scoring
Click to highlight new comments since:
[-]Ruby60

These papers on viral load probably help inform the answer. It was flagged to me that Ct might not have straightforward interpretation, but I haven't looked into it. So posting these as resources.

https://www.thelancet.com/journals/laninf/article/PIIS1473-3099(20)30113-4/fulltext?fbclid=IwAR3crOZxhVP1eVPMcO_wujJBxHFAjp2fj4_jNj30ld_nVcKTqtcT1IjXozI

https://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMc2001737

Reply
[-]Scott Garrabrant50

You should (more strongly?) disambiguate between how long after being sick are you safe, or how long after being 100% isolated are you safe.

Reply
[-]Raemon20

Updated OP to explicitly flag that there are two sub-questions here. (I assume both will benefit from similar aggregated information)

Reply
[-]Sjcs10

TL;DR We don't know, it's variable case to case, and could be longer than 25 days from symptom onset if you get sick

In patients admitted to hospital with COVID-19, there are cases (Korea, Singapore) of viral RNA detectable up to 25 days after symptom onset. This is not the same as still being infective, so we don't really know.

In people exposed to SARS-CoV-2, 14 days is an estimation that the vast majority will have developed symptoms by this time (here). However, this doesn't take into account cases that remain asymptomatic throughout their infection (maybe 15-20% from Diamond Princess data)

Reply
Moderation Log
More from Raemon
View more
Curated and popular this week
A
34