Right, agreed.
But...
For clarity, I label P the original parent and C the original child.
If C had read "If you think this shouldn't be a top level post, upvote this comment and downvote the parent." then it would have worked out fine.
That is, suppose ten people vote, 8 pro and 2 con.
P, in that case, would have 8 upvotes and 2 downvotes = 6 karma; C would have 2 upvotes and 8 downvotes = -6 karma; Net karma to dorrika = 0.
More efficient than the traditional "upvote this for yes" "upvote this for no" "downvote this for balance" arrangement... though perhaps more confusing.
I assumed that's what dorrika was trying to do originally and had just typoed C... but I guess I was wrong.
Thanks for the correction.
If C had read "If you think this shouldn't be a top level post, upvote this comment and downvote the parent." then it would have worked out fine.
That is, suppose ten people vote, 8 pro and 2 con.
P, in that case, would have 8 upvotes and 2 downvotes = 6 karma; C would have 2 upvotes and 8 downvotes = -6 karma; Net karma to dorrika = 0.
That system does work, but I find it less informative. Under that system, if you come back a day later and find that P and C have karma 2 and -2, then you don't know if a) only one person thinks it should be top-level and the rest don't care or b) 15 people think it should be top-level but 14 think it should stay in discussion.
In Anna’s recent post, she talked about training your mind to notice when it wasn’t curious about something and scream “Error! Look for a different way to do this” in such cases. Johnicholas and TheOtherDave's list of what stupidity feels like also looks useful for this purpose. I'm creating this post to make a more comprehensive list of feelings which indicate that people should reanalyze different possible paths to make sure that the one which they're taking is the most effective one to their objective.
Please suggest additions to the list in your comments -- I'll move them up here (along with links to further explanation, if given.) Keep in mind that your description of the feeling should be as illustrative as possible. For example, "feeling stupid" is unhelpful, while "you feel like you've taken a wrong turn into a never-ending tunnel" is better. Of course, metaphors which are immediately understood by some people may not be so easily understood by others, so try to give a more detailed description of the feeling if other people express that you're probably saying more than they're hearing.
List: "Error! Look for a different way to do this" if you feel like: