I don't like this comment, and now I'm conflicted about how to deal with that.
Arguments? Tell me why Karma isn't a mind killer. Your comment makes me conclude that you would have usually just downvoted my comment to signal that you don't agree but since I especially asked for as many downvotes as possible that option is gone.
Karma just doesn't work in a lot of cases. People are not superhuman AGI's who can infer what is wrong with their submission by a mere vote. Voting will just cause them to shut up about what they really think. In a few cases someone might conclude that the more intelligent and rational collective intelligence of LW decided that their submission is wrong and subsequently think about what is wrong. But in the long run, and for everyone who doesn't think like that, Karma will just create an echo chamber or at the very least a place where being political correct is much more important than being honest.
Tell me why Karma isn't a mind killer.
I have a video on the virtues of reputation systems: Universal karma.
I just watched Transcendent Man about the singularity and Ray Kurzweil in particular. It's well-made, full-length, and includes the most popular criticisms of Kurzweil: that his prediction timeframes are driven by his own hope for immortality, that the timescale of his other predictions are too optimistic, that his predictions about the social outcomes of revolutionary technology are naively optimistic, and so on. Ben Goertzel and others get much face time.
You can rent or buy it on iTunes.