Yes, if saving birds is the best use of your entire charity budget, then you should give the whole $100 to save birds. Agreed.
And, yes, if you've spent your entire charity budget on charity, then you don't give more. Agreed.
I can't tell whether you're under the impression that either of those points are somehow responsive to my point (or to the original article), or whether you're not trying to be responsive.
I was describing how I would respond in that situation. The amount I would give to charity XYZ is completely determined by my income. I need you to explain to me why this is wrong.
I've created a new website for my ebook Facing the Intelligence Explosion:
This page is the dedicated discussion page for Facing the Intelligence Explosion.
If you'd like to comment on a particular chapter, please give the chapter name at top of your comment so that others can more easily understand your comment. For example: