Comment on [META] 'Rational' vs 'Optimized'

Sat, 07 Jan 2012 21:10:34 GMT

What we frequently refer to here as a "rational agent" isn't an optimized agent, it's an optimizing agent -- one that makes the decisions that most effectively implement its goals.

I am reminded of one of the early videos in Norvig and Thrun's recent online AI class, where "optimal" was used in two different senses in rapid succession — to mean "the algorithm yields the shortest route" and "the algorithm executes in the best time". This yielded some confusion for a friend of mine, who assumed that the speaker meant that these were both aspects of some deeper definition of "optimal" which would then be explained. No such explanation was forthcoming.

Discuss