Hmm. Actually, I love Evangelion for other reasons that Madoka doesn't have. Bokurano is the more appropriate comparison.

I think Bokurano might actually be better than Madoka by a pure aesthetic of cosmic horror - there's no eucatastrophe in Bokurano, just staring-into-the-abyss-without-flinching. On the other hand, it's not actually any fun to watch.

EDIT: OMG I JUST HAD THE BEST CROSSOVER IDEA. Vaphongbef irefhf Qhat Orrgyr'f pbagebyyref sbe gur hygvzngr hasevraqyl-havirefr-bcgvzvfngvba fubjqbja.