You're looking at Less Wrong's discussion board. This includes all posts, including those that haven't been promoted to the front page yet. For more information, see About Less Wrong.
Comment author:gwern
25 April 2012 05:59:32PM
8 points
[-]
I clicked, and was very disappointed. What might a version of my Death Note essay for Harry Potter have looked like? I had no idea but dearly wanted to find out.
To explain my downvote: both the title and the description of this post are misleading, and the link itself is not particularly interesting. A better title and description might reduce the number of downvotes you get.
Comment author:gjm
26 April 2012 12:00:44AM
0 points
[-]
I wouldn't be terribly surprised if David MacKay has heard of HPMOR, actually. Also, the textbook pitted against Harry Potter there is very good indeed.
(Also: although I can see why this post got downvoted, I really don't think it deserves to be at -8.)
Comments (4)
I clicked, and was very disappointed. What might a version of my Death Note essay for Harry Potter have looked like? I had no idea but dearly wanted to find out.
To explain my downvote: both the title and the description of this post are misleading, and the link itself is not particularly interesting. A better title and description might reduce the number of downvotes you get.
I have the paperback edition of MacKay's book. A lot cheaper than thirty pounds.
I wouldn't be terribly surprised if David MacKay has heard of HPMOR, actually. Also, the textbook pitted against Harry Potter there is very good indeed.
(Also: although I can see why this post got downvoted, I really don't think it deserves to be at -8.)