After about 10 months of almost daily use of this lighting, I have not noticed any decrease in effectiveness.
Thank you for waiting to see whether this works in the long term before posting.
If you do, please provide feedback on whether it works as well for you as it does for me. Any questions?
Why not do a self-experiment? It's not like turning on lights is hard to randomize.
Of course you can tell the difference. That just means that your self-experiment is not blinded (if you'll pardon the pun).
I've seen the light as well. Fiat lux!
Also like your argumentum ad savannam africanus. That should be a thing. Recreating the desert's albedo.
Well, shouldn't it be "argumentum ad savannam africanam", if the adjective refers to the savanna (which is feminine singular accusative), or eventually "africanum", if it binds to the argumentum (which is neuter singular nominative)?
First time commenting here. A friend linked this thread on Facebook, and have something to add about the possible mechanisms of light therapy.
So far as I am aware, the mood and concentration enhancing effects of light therapy work primarily on the Serotonin -> Melatonin synthesis that occurs in our brains.
Basically, when it gets dark and gloomy, our brains start manufacturing melatonin, to make us feel tired and sleepy. In animals such as bears, the winter induced melatonin is a signal that it is time to hibernate.
The interesting part is that the chemical from which melatonin is synthesized is serotonin, which as we know is involved in mood, appetite, sleep and all sorts of human behaviour, and is the primary neurotransmitter system targeted by SSRI antidepressants.
Hence less light causes more serotonin to turn into melatonin, which makes us feel both tired and potentially moody. Therefore its reasonable to hypothesize that light therapy works by reducing the rate of melatonin synthesis and maintaining higher levels of serotonin.
I have never heard of light therapy affecting adenosine levels in the brain. This doesn't mean that it doesn't, just that I am unaware of evidence that...
Anja and I just went out and bought three 120W lights (for construction sites; we had trouble getting good bulbs).
Here at the Singularity Institute, we take ideas seriously.
We bought three of these.
We've tried to put them around the room evenly. You can see all three in the right picture (one in the foreground). We'll report back in a few weeks about how much it helped.
My personal subjective experience is also that I find very bright artificial light after dark improves my mood, alertness and cognitive ability.
However, the personal subjective experience isn't universal: many people I've shared home or work spaces with have complained when I've installed bright lighting. They've found it too bright, or too clinical, or too much glare, or gives them a headache or eyestrain. I have several co-workers who routinely turn off office lights (which I'd prefer to be even brighter) and replace them with dim uplighters.
Also, I'm not at all sure that my personal subjective experience is a robust effect.
The effect of lighting on human productivity is the canonical example of a difficult-to-study phenomenon. The Hawthorne Effect - where research shows an effect of an intervention because some research is being done - is legendarily named after some studies in to the effect on factory productivity of lighting. The story goes that increasing lighting increased productivity - and then changing it back to what it was before also increased productivity. The truth is a little more complicated than that - the Wikipedia article on the Hawthorne Effect touches on some...
I also have been using bright lights to help stay alert. This has helped a lot getting used to polyphasic sleep. (It also helps to use a sleep mask. Bright light while awake, no light while sleeping.) Since I started, I have noticed that I have less need for this effect, but it is still nice.
I had looked into the light therapy bulbs, but the price made me think I should at least try the brighter conventional bulbs first, and this turned out to work fine.
With the understanding that I only have a few minutes to check for research data:
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/1801013
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/21298068 - "cognitive response ... to light at levels as low as 40 lux, is blue-shifted"
Thanks for a useful practical tip.
the color of the light doesn't actually make a difference. The amount of light does.
Is that your own observation, or the result of broader research ? I always wondered if light "temperature" did affect mood/awakeness and found contradictory results when making a quick search, so I still have a blank spot on my map on that.
I think it'd be interesting to do some formal data collection on this idea even if there isn't going to be any control group. If you would, please PM me or comment in this thread if you're planning to try it out, and I will contact everyone who said they were trying it out in a few months and put together a short report.
Edit: Or put your email in this form.
You can get CFL bulbs at the 105-watt level, and they're huge but bright and daylight-balanced too.
I recently bought this: http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B005FRCUHY/ref=oh_details_o06_s00_i00
Unfortunately out of stock now, but it was under $30 for a 2-pack at the time. Note that I had to discard a smelly 65W bulb from Square Perfect, but LimoStudios seems able to handle its own heat. 2x 105W CFLs makes a brilliant blue-white light that does seem a bit like daylight.
If anyone knows of a floor lamp that will shade standard-socket light bulbs that are li...
I've noticed the same effect after installing 240 watts (that is, 25kLumens) of LED lighting in my living room. I stay more alert while they're on, and then pretty much crash when they turn off or I leave the room.
That was for an aquarium, though, and that much lighting actually is pretty expensive up-front.
David Chapman has a neat method for getting a very large amount of light/lumens very cheaply in upfront & operating costs: use LED light bars sold for vehicular use and rewire them for normal household electricity consumption.
I found a cheap lux meter helpful in convincing myself to actually make a change in my lighting. I moved my workspace lighting from 130lux at my desk to 500lux , and have found it easier to stay alert in the evenings.
I believe it also improved my ability to judge indoor lighting levels, but haven't tested this.
Good stuff. i recommend daylight-spectrum CFLs - about £5 each off eBay for 22W (100W-equivalent), compared to £2 in the shops for the horrible yellow 22W. I fill my house with these, and they really are just so much nicer than anything that isn't daylight-spectrum.
If anyone is curious, my estimate of a potentially similar effect based on the weather would require a self-experiment of only ~70 days. I hope someone does run one.
EDIT: with additional data, the correlation has shrunk and so the necessary n has increased substantially to 1600 days.
How much did this cost you?
The cheapest solution for very bright light that I'm aware of is something like these photography bulbs: http://www.amazon.com/CowboyStudio-105-Fluorescent-Daylight-Photography/dp/B004L75BGQ/ref=sr_1_2?ie=UTF8&qid=1358542854&sr=8-2&keywords=photography+lightbulb ($15/bulb, ~4500 lumens from each)
but I'd be interested if others have found cheaper solutions.
Good thing you reminded me.
I've had problems with motivation and mood.
I had a light box that I set across the room for a month, and my mood and motivation both improved. Got out of the habit of using it.
I've noticed a stimulating effect for the rest of the day just from being in the Home Depot lighting department for 20 minutes.
Another SAD light treatment I haven't tried because it's annoyingly pricey (~$300) for the materials involved:
...Valkee Bright Light Headset Valkee substitutes the mood-elevating effects of the sun, by channeling bright light direc
It's funny. I use F.Lux both on my phone and computer and turn on my light to help wake up in the morning but I've never really thought about optimizing with more than averagely bright lights.
I bought these with a 4 socket adapter. However, I think my lamp can't power them all. Does anyone know a higher output lamp?
Actually I'm not even sure if that is how lights work. If someone can explain how I can the power that goes to the light bulbs, it'd be greatly appreciated.
Most of the comments on this thread are about people who seem to find this useful or think that this will make a difference positively. While I think the idea interesting, and would like to try it out, I am one of those who don't seem to like really bright lighting. In fact, at work, I've had some of the overhead lights removed to make it generally less bright ambiently. I tend to suffer from eyestrain or seem to get a headache, though now that I think about it, I am not sure if this was because the over head lights were reflecting badly off of my computer...
I like to make things dark so I can sleep better; I currently sleep with my head under multiple blankets. This means that I don't actually get any light in the morning until the blankets come off of my head. And that causes its own set of problems.
In recent months I have been going to my doctor about a sleep condition- I frequently and uncontrollably fall asleep at a particular time of day (about 8pm to 11pm). In my own experimentation I have found that bright light is one of the best ways to deal with this. In fact I am considering moving in order to help, as my current apartment has only lamps.
105 watts of incandescents with halogen gas, billed as the equivalent of 130 watts of incandescent light. And I got an adaptor like this that lets me screw four of those into the same socket in the ceiling.
I'm unclear on the physics of lightning. If you have four lights that are the equivalent of 130 watts each, is the light output equivalent to a single 520 watt light? Or is there some sort of nonlinear effect?
Hi, that's technically incorrect. It's forbidden to sell them as a general home light source, it's legal to sell them for special uses. The net result is that you can still buy them everywhere (supermarkets, online, etc), only they're labeled as a "shock-resistant light bulb, not for home use" or as a "glowing electrical heater". The price is up about 5% and quality is slightly lower (shorter life) as now they're all from China, local factories were unfortunately closed following the ban. Overall, it's a ridiculously dead law.
If you live in eu country and you really can't buy them locally (which would be really weird), I guess I could buy some and send them to you
I don't like light.
I have noticed that once it gets dark outside, I have to turn on the light in my room to be at all productive.
I wonder if wiring bright lights to turn on automatically will lead to more alertness in the morning. I find alarm clocks jarring and the first 5 minutes of being awake feels awful. Perhaps having light wake you is more natural?
This is a simple idea that I came up with by myself. I was looking for a means to enter high functioning lots-of-beta-waves modes without the use of chemical stimulants. What I found was that very bright light works really, really well.
I got the brightest light bulbs I could get cheaply. 105 watts of incandescents with halogen gas, billed as the equivalent of 130 watts of incandescent light. And I got an adaptor like this that lets me screw four of those into the same socket in the ceiling. The result is about as painful to look at as the sun. It makes my (small) room brighter than a clear summer's day at my latitude and slightly brighter than a supermarket.
I guess it affects adenosine much like caffeine does because that's what it feels like. Yet unlike caffeine, it can be rapidly turned on and off, literally with the flip of a switch.
For waking up in the morning, I find bright light more effective than a 200mg caffeine tablet, although my caffeine tolerance is moderate for a scientist.
I have not compared the effects of very bright light to modafinil, which requires a prescription in my country.
When under this amount of light, I need to remind myself to go to bed, because I tire about three hours later than with common luminosity. Yet once I switch it off, I can usually sleep within a few minutes, as (I'm guessing) a flood of unblocked adenosine suddenly overwhelms me. I used to have those unproductive late hours where I was too awake to sleep but too tired to be smart. I don't have those anymore.
You've probably heard of light therapy, which uses light to help manage seasonal affective disorder. I don't have that issue, but I definitely notice that the light does improve my mood. (Maybe that's simply because I like to function well.) I'm pretty sure the expensive "light therapy bulbs" you can get are scams, because the color of the light doesn't actually make a difference. The amount of light does.
One nice side benefit is that it keeps me awake while meditating, so I don't need the upright posture that usually does that job. Without the need for an upright posture, I can go beyond two hours straight, which helps enter more profoundly altered states.
After about 10 months of almost daily use of this lighting, I have not noticed any decrease in effectiveness. I do notice I find normally-lit rooms comparatively gloomy, and have an increasingly hard time understanding why people tolerate that. Supermarkets and offices are brightly lit to make the rats move faster - why don't we do that at our homes and while we're at it, amp it up even further? After all, our brains were made for the African savanna, which during the day is a lot brighter than most apartments today.
Since everyone can try this for a few bucks, I hope some of you will. If you do, please provide feedback on whether it works as well for you as it does for me. Any questions?