RomeoStevens comments on Exercise isn't necessarily good for people - Less Wrong Discussion
You are viewing a comment permalink. View the original post to see all comments and the full post content.
You are viewing a comment permalink. View the original post to see all comments and the full post content.
Comments (53)
The idea that blood pressure is an adequate proxy for overall health is highly dubious and I wouldn't draw conclusions about longevity from it. Even if the inference was valid blood pressure is notoriously unreliable because it is affected by so many variables.
Here's a variable that might not be well known-- doctors and hospitals don't always have large blood pressure cuffs, so they use cuffs that are too small on fat patients, and get inaccurately high blood pressure readings as a result.
Seriously? This is really embarrassing. Like, how hard can it be to get some valid data around here?
Harder than you can imagine.
Decline in autopsy rates
Autopsies supply significant information
Related: math.ucla.edu/~scp/publications/mortality.PDF
Thanks.
This may imply some heuristics. Don't trust linear corelations in biology. Don't trust thresholds which are supposed to apply to everyone, or almost everyone. Be dubious about round numbers.
I agree blood pressure is a generally a poor predictor of health or mortality.
This is often measured because it is easy to measure, rather than it being particularly informative.
Aelephant - that's a good paper with data on this. I needed to edit that link to http://www.math.ucla.edu/~scp/publications/mortality.PDF for the pdf download to work.