Another blackmail attempt:
I own steamy and revealing letters about our affair. I've boarded them up in a cave. Then the entrance to the cave starts to crumble: soon it will fall open, and the letters will blow out, for all the world to read.
I own the land the cave is on, and refuse to let anyone fix the cave, unless you pay me. Blackmail?
What about if the only reason the cave entrance was crumbling was because I diverted a river. I didn't do this with the intent of causing the entrance to crumble (I have other reasons), but I was fully aware of this side effect, and let it happen. Blackmail?
What if I approached you before I diverted the river, and asked for money then. I still want to divert the river, but if you pay up enough, I will desist from it. Blackmail?
I own the land the cave is on, and refuse to let anyone fix the cave, unless you pay me. Blackmail?
Yes.
What about if the only reason the cave entrance was crumbling was because I diverted a river. I didn't do this with the intent of causing the entrance to crumble (I have other reasons), but I was fully aware of this side effect, and let it happen. Blackmail?
No. Assuming that protecting the cave is free (because someone else wants to come and do it) the diverting of the river is not itself blackmail. Subsequent blackmail is still blackmail. It becom...
My blackmail posts have generated some interesting discussion, so I'm just creating this one so that people can post examples of behaviours that they think are either clearly blackmail, or clearly not blackmail, or something in between.