You're looking at Less Wrong's discussion board. This includes all posts, including those that haven't been promoted to the front page yet. For more information, see About Less Wrong.

seez comments on Interesting new Pew Research study on American opinions about radical life extension - Less Wrong Discussion

10 [deleted] 09 August 2013 05:26PM

You are viewing a comment permalink. View the original post to see all comments and the full post content.

Comments (21)

You are viewing a single comment's thread. Show more comments above.

Comment author: seez 09 August 2013 06:56:56PM *  6 points [-]

I think another possible reason for the negative correlation with age is that as people get older and death becomes more imminent, they (in my experience) try harder to convince themselves and their peers that it is a good/natural/acceptable thing, to lessen the sense of fear and helplessness.

The median ideal life span is 90 years – about 11 years longer than the current average U.S. life expectancy, which is 78.7 years

I'd guess that there's nothing magically wonderful about living to be 90. The more important part seems to be wanting to live longer but not wanting (or wanting to want) anything that seems implausible or socially abnormal.

It would have been interesting to see if greater age was correlated with holding a stronger view either for or against radical life extension. I would predict that older people hold stronger views, since the issue is more relevant to their current life experiences.

Younger adults, to whom old age may seem far away, are more likely than those 65 and older to give an ideal age of 78 years or less (19% vs. 6%). The median ideal life span of adults under 30 – at 85 years – is lower than that for older adults.

I did not expect this. And it seems weird, since young people are also more optimistic about their futures. And more likely to want to undergo radical life extension. Plus they haven't suffered the effects of aging (having many loved ones die, illness and pain, etc.).

Comment author: [deleted] 09 August 2013 07:13:33PM *  2 points [-]

Old people may be against radical life extension in principle, but they don't personally want to die just yet. I'd be curious to see what the typical 90 year old lists as their ideal life span; or more generally, at what age (if ever) people start actively wanting to die soon, measured as listing an ideal life span within 5 years of their current age.

Comment author: Lumifer 09 August 2013 07:50:48PM 3 points [-]

at what age (if ever) people start actively wanting to die soon

I don't think that wish to die is directly correlated with age -- I think it's mostly a function of the state of one's health (which is correlated with age, of course) and the consequent quality of life.

Comment author: [deleted] 10 August 2013 02:32:12AM *  3 points [-]

That's my intuition as well: that someone who lists 90 as their ideal life span while young and then makes it to 89 without obtaining some debilitating and painful illness will change their mind about dying at 90. The fact that older people list higher ideal life spans despite being less gung-ho on life extension in principle suggests to me that "wanting to die eventually" is Far. I wouldn't be surprised if there was no age at which the median person wanted to die soon, no matter what their youthful ideals about aging may have been.

Comment author: Fadeway 10 August 2013 04:16:27AM -1 points [-]

I did not expect this. And it seems weird, since young people are also more optimistic about their futures. And more likely to want to undergo radical life extension. Plus they haven't suffered the effects of aging (having many loved ones die, illness and pain, etc.).

Didn't predictions for the Singularity follow a similar trend? Older people predicting 30-40 years until the event, and younger predictors being more pessimistic because they're likely to still be alive even if it happens in 60 years?

Comment author: gwern 10 August 2013 06:11:54PM 6 points [-]