You're supposed to have the rubber duck ask these questions too.
The difference here was that I was actually writing a letter / forum post that other people could have seen. I was doing this with the urgency of 'If there's an obvious solution to this, I'm going to look like a moron'. In contrast, a rubber duck, well... it's just me.
I think the distinction you drew in the other branch of this conversation is more important. Getting a little skin in the game of 'get this right now (or satisfy yourself that it's genuinely hard)'.
This is the public group instrumental rationality diary for October 1-15.
New this month: If you have preferences about the future frequency of rationality diary posts, please express them in the poll below!
Thanks to cata for starting the Group Rationality Diary posts, and to commenters for participating.
Immediate past diary: September 16-30
Rationality diaries archive