gattsuru comments on Open Thread, November 15-22, 2013 - Less Wrong Discussion
You are viewing a comment permalink. View the original post to see all comments and the full post content.
You are viewing a comment permalink. View the original post to see all comments and the full post content.
Comments (257)
I'd strongly caution against fighting a false version of your opponent. Even among biblical literalists, very nearly none believe in a -spherical- (EDIT: flat, thank you for catching the typo) Earth (often citing parts of the bible that call the world a sphere!), and that's been the case for over a millennium. And while the movie probably will have impossible space CGI shenanigans, even the Creationist idiots tend to think of things in terms of "kind" rather than "species" (and often don't understand the later's definition), and try to create some artificial dividing line between macroevolution and animal husbandry.
The original Jewish version would probably go that way, since it was closer to a cataclysm/Ragnarok event in that belief structure. Modern Christian translations generally just turn it into rain. Given that the actions of a literal magic sky being are part of the premise...
That's not to say Biblical Literalism or Creationism is particularly coherent, nor that it's likely to be a good movie, of course.
Is this a typo for "very nearly none believe in a flat Earth"?
Gah, yes. Thank you for catching that.
I'm a little surprised no one caught it sooner.
This failure mode of saying the reverse of what was meant is called misnegation. Often it's accompanied by readers or listeners taking the intended meaning without noticing the mistake.
I saw it sooner, but posting a correction seemed nitpicky.
Still, if they could pull it off in a way that makes internal sense, that'd be kind of an awesome feat.
The Old Testament does not describe Earth as a 3D sphere but as a flat circle.