Eugine_Nier comments on LINK: In favor of niceness, community, and civilisation - Less Wrong Discussion
You are viewing a comment permalink. View the original post to see all comments and the full post content.
You are viewing a comment permalink. View the original post to see all comments and the full post content.
Comments (137)
The problem with Yvain's reply is that he omits the main reason why lying is a bad idea. Yvain compares lying to violence. I don't think this is a good comparison. It's acceptable to respond to violence with violence. It's not a good idea to respond to lies with lies.
Eliezer touched on this issue in his post here where he pointed out that one problem with lying to support a cause is that you'd better be absolutely sure that all your beliefs about the cause and what to do for it are in fact correct. However, the problem is even worse, there is a vicious cycle here since a cause that frequently lies is much more likely to acquire incorrect beliefs.
Think about it this way: suppose you believe that your cause justifies lying, so you lie about it. Your lies attract people to your cause who believe those lies. They in turn make up further lies (that they think are justified based on the lies they believe to be true). And so no until your cause's belief system is full of falsehoods and anti-epistomology. Your cause may ultimately "win" in the sense that it's followers acquire power, but by that point said followers may no longer care about your original goal. Even if they do, they're likely to have so many false beliefs that what they do to accomplish it is likely to be counter-productive and probably have other unpleasant side effects.
Note that the above argument applies to lying but not to violence. Thus in some sense lying for your cause is in fact worse than committing violence for it.
A pithy way of summarizing the above comment:
If someone tells you his cause is so important that lying for it is justified, assume he's lying.
This wins my personal "rationality quote of the decade" award.