solipsist comments on [LINK] Elon Musk interested in AI safety - Less Wrong Discussion
You are viewing a comment permalink. View the original post to see all comments and the full post content.
You are viewing a comment permalink. View the original post to see all comments and the full post content.
Comments (15)
I don't fault using incorrect analogies. It's often easier to direct people to an idea from inaccurate but known territory than along a consistently accurate path.
It seems to me that Musk is trying to point to the idea that AIs may have unexpected dangers, not to any danger in particular.
But Musk starts with mentioning "Terminator". There's plenty of sf literature showing much more accuratly danger of AI, though none of them as widely known as "Terminator".
That AI may have unexpected dangers seems too vague to me, to expect Musk to think along lines of LWers.
Terminator is way more popular than the others.
2001? Not catastrophic enough.
I, Robot (the movie)? Not nearly as popular or classic, and it features a comparatively easy solution
Terminator has '99% of humanity wiped out, let's really REALLY avoid this scenario' AND 'computers following directions exactly, not accomplishing what intended'