You're looking at Less Wrong's discussion board. This includes all posts, including those that haven't been promoted to the front page yet. For more information, see About Less Wrong.

skeptical_lurker comments on [POLITICS] Jihadism and a new kind of existential threat - Less Wrong Discussion

-5 Post author: MrMind 25 March 2015 09:37AM

You are viewing a comment permalink. View the original post to see all comments and the full post content.

Comments (143)

You are viewing a single comment's thread. Show more comments above.

Comment author: skeptical_lurker 26 March 2015 09:40:15PM 1 point [-]

Its only slightly higher than the quiverfull people, so I'd say its only a little implausible, rather than total bullshit.

Comment author: satt 27 March 2015 04:21:52AM *  0 points [-]

A priori, an average of 6 is in the realm of possibility if it's a total fertility rate. Two decades ago the highest national-level European TFR was in Kosovo, where Albanian women had a TFR around 6.5. So Muscovite Tatar women having a TFR of 6 nowadays could be just about possible.

I have a hard time, though, believing that Muscovite Chechen & Ingush women are breaking double digits; that'd be off the national charts. One miiiiight be able to bend over backwards to explain that away as a Moscow-and-ethnicity-specific anomaly, but I'm not sure how.

I poked around a bit to try uncovering more data on Tatar women in Moscow, but couldn't find anything quickly on Google Scholar which had Moscow-specific TFRs by ethnicity. One paper does use 1989 census data to find that in Russia as a whole, ethnic Russian & Tatar women aged 50-54 averaged 1.88 & 2.65 "children ever born" respectively. 2.65 is a lot lower than 6, so either (1) Moscow Tatars are astoundingly prolific compared to Tatars elsewhere in Russia; (2) Russian Tatar women have most of their babies post-menopause; (3) Russian Tatar women, reversing their earlier demographic transition, have more than doubled their TFR in the last 25 years; or (4) "In Moscow, Tatar women have six children [...] on average" is BS. A blog post with blunter but more recent data is suggestive of (4).

Comment author: Lumifer 27 March 2015 02:31:21PM -1 points [-]

Quiverfull people self-select into having lots of children. Women of a particular ethnic background do not.