Nebu comments on Perceptual Entropy and Frozen Estimates - Less Wrong Discussion
You are viewing a comment permalink. View the original post to see all comments and the full post content.
You are viewing a comment permalink. View the original post to see all comments and the full post content.
Comments (20)
Feedback:
I've had to calculate information entropy for a data compression course, so I felt like I already knew the concepts you were trying to explain here, but I was not able to follow your explanation at all.
The total what? Total entropy for the two dice that you have? For just one of those two dice? log(1/6) is a negative number, so why do I not see any negative numbers used in your equation? There are 6 states, so I guess that sort of explains why you're multiplying some figure by 6, but why are you dividing by 6?
Why do you suddenly switch from the notation 1/2 to the notation 0.5? Is that significant (they're referring to different concepts who coincidentally happen to have equal values)? If they actually refer to the same value, why do we have the positive value 1/2, but negative value -0.5?
Suggestion:
6 * (1/6) * 2.585 = 2.585for one example (where all the factors are positive) and then(-0.5*-1)+(-0.5*-1)=1for another example (where we rely on pairs of negative factors to become positive).