Such as should not be atheist - if not figurehead people would care more about culturally Christian / traditional / conservative VALUES than faith.
The point is that in the USA faith is (or at least was) a reasonable signal for values.
My answer will be that a hyper-masculine nationalist even when atheist will have 90% the same values.
Due to the cultural history of the USA hyper-masculine nationalist atheists with conservative values are rare. Currently the only place to find them is in certain corners of NRx.
I just saw that Donald Trump is running for president. Which led me to the following thought: would any of the big names in tech have a chance at being elected president of the US? Elon Musk? Sergey Brin? Jeff Bezos? Reid Hoffman? Peter Thiel? Edit: Bill Gates?
Some follow up questions/thoughts:
Edit: hypothetically, if one of these big-name tech people were to try to gain political power, how should they go about doing so?