You're looking at Less Wrong's discussion board. This includes all posts, including those that haven't been promoted to the front page yet. For more information, see About Less Wrong.

Jiro comments on Examples of growth mindset or practice in fiction - Less Wrong Discussion

12 Post author: Swimmer963 28 September 2015 09:47PM

You are viewing a comment permalink. View the original post to see all comments and the full post content.

Comments (32)

You are viewing a single comment's thread. Show more comments above.

Comment author: Jiro 01 October 2015 08:49:52PM 0 points [-]

I think the only thing that actually improved with use and training is the Rasengan, and even that didn't require any training to gain initially.

But

He trained for a few months and became much better than at least one of them who practiced it all his life (Jiraya)

He trained for several weeks to accomplish it. We don't know if this unusual,

To be fair, he does train a lot at being nice - at least he practices it all the time.

Now of course he also knows the basic techniques that all ninjas know, and he does train the acquire and to improve them.

You're not really arguing that he doesn't train except for the Rasengan. You're arguing that he does train, but that training works better for him than for other people because of his unearned advantages, so his training doesn't really count

But everything you train in works that way. I know how to program a computer. I had to train to do so, but there are other people who would have to train much longer to do the same thing and still other people who could not do it no matter how much training they did. That doesn't mean I didn't train, or that my ability to do it is entirely due to luck, even though it's certainly partly due to luck.

All the things that make him powerful, important, interesting, and not-dead-long-ago are plot armor and unearned gifts. Take all of them away and he literally wouldn't have made it out of the Ninja Academy.

And if you take away my computer programming potential--a potential which not every person has--I literally wouldn't have made it out of a real-life academy. I still trained in it.

Comment author: DanArmak 02 October 2015 11:33:50AM 0 points [-]

You're not really arguing that he doesn't train except for the Rasengan. You're arguing that he does train, but that training works better for him than for other people because of his unearned advantages, so his training doesn't really count

No. I'm arguing that the things he trains at are not the things that make him successful. Even if he trained much less, he would still achieve all the same outcomes due to his unique unearned untrained powers. He succeeds because he's a privileged magical shonen protagonist, not because he's training rigorously.

Comment author: Jiro 02 October 2015 03:31:51PM *  0 points [-]

Even if he trained much less, he would still achieve all the same outcomes due to his unique unearned untrained powers.

I don't believe this. Using your own example, he got senjutsu, and trained for a few months to get good at it. Without that training, would he have had the same outcome? (Remember that shadow clone acts as a training multiplier, but the multiplier doesn't do any good if there is zero training to multiply.) Without training to use the kyuubi's chakra (another example of yours), would he have achieved the same outcome?

(Edit: I'm not sure he was able to use shadow clone with senjutsu, so ignore that if it doesn't apply.)

Comment author: DanArmak 02 October 2015 07:54:45PM 0 points [-]

I said "if he trained much less", not "if he didn't train at all". For senjutsu and the Kyuubi's chakra he had to train less than others who did it before him, and achieved better results than some of them did. For the other things on my list, he didn't need to train at all.

My list was supposed to show that his skills tend to follow my analysis, not that all them do so perfectly. I still think it's a good generalization.