So? Assign zeroes to these points in some kind of score you keep when reading the list, or embrace the metaphor (can I rent or timeshare a rutabaga? That is, I have some rutabagas this week because my mom is coming to visit and she loves this mysterious vegetable, and than next week I give some rutabaga seed or whatever to the kindly farmer, or maybe just show the rutabaga to my mom and boast, in passing, of my gardening skills and then return it to the kindly farmer on the quiet side... Or, what are the rutabaga's power options and repair costs - that is, does cultivating them enrich the soil or deplete it, and how long can one grow them in the same spot, and do they get hit with weird parasites that would mess with my glorious potatoes and I will end up spending money and time trying to set things right -)
(Also, I don't feel like this is a productive discussion to have:(, since if you consider just one place where you buy rutabagas, it is strictly a subset of you considering n places, for which Elo's list totally applies.)
or embrace the metaphor
Do note where we started :-D
I don't feel like this is a productive discussion to have
It's not particularly productive for rutabaga-buying purposes. It might be productive for thinking about what matters and what doesn't. Matching the effort to the expected change in outcome, y'know...
The following is an incomplete list of suggestions for generic considerations that you might like to make when you go out to buy a thing. I have tried to put the list in order; being generic - certain things will be more or less important in different orders.
0. Do I need the thing? Am I just wanting it on a whim (you are allowed to do that, but at least try to not do that for many expensive things that don’t have resale value)? If a month had gone by, would I still be wanting it?
Consider your options that avoid buying it:
Some items are perfectly fine second hand, i.e. books, whereas others are potentially less fine (i.e. cars) where more can go wrong with a second hand one. The point of this inclusion was to encourage you to consider it when you previously would not have. for whichever reason. Books second hand can also be occasionally out of date or damaged; and cars second hand can be excellent purchases.
Knowledge about the thing:
Purchase considerations:
General specifics:
Miscellaneous considerations:
Nearly all of the points listed here could be expanded to its own post. These points apply to everyone to different extents. “Considering borrowing” is advice that is priceless to one person, and useless to another person. similarly; “budget” might be significant to one person because they don’t spend often but then spend whatever they like when they need to; but useless to another person because they live and breathe budget.
I plan to cover this in another post about making advice applicable to you.
meta: 3 hours write up. 3-5 reviewers, slack channel inspiring the post, and giving me a place to flesh out the thoughts.
This post is certainly open to improvements. Please add your comments below.
See also: My Table of contents for other posts in this collection.
See also other repositories on lesswrong: