CronoDAS comments on The Thyroid Madness : Core Argument, Evidence, Probabilities and Predictions - Less Wrong Discussion
You are viewing a comment permalink. View the original post to see all comments and the full post content.
You are viewing a comment permalink. View the original post to see all comments and the full post content.
Comments (132)
Never mind. My original source was my father (who's usually pretty reliable when it comes to pseudoscience) but apparently the current Cochrane review says it's no better than placebo. (The subluxation theory of chiropractic is nonsense, but it's not ridiculous that fiddling with someone's back can relieve back pain - massages, for example, tend to feel good.)
(http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/m/pubmed/23169072/?i=3&from=/22972127/related)
The thing you linked is not from Cochrane. They say:
http://www.cochrane.org/CD005427/BACK_combined-chiropractic-interventions-for-low-back-pain
I paraphrase: (it works, a bit, it's as good as anything else as far as we know, we have no clue really, further research is needed.)
That looks like science. I am glad they do what they do.
Your dad might be right! This is from NICE (British recommendations for national treatment, a very sane system in my opinion, they try not to waste public money on things that don't work or are too expensive)
I have found over the years that a single session every year or so obliterates a problem that, if left unmessed-with becomes painful and eventually restricts my ability to play various sports.
The first time it was done (I was about 25?), a short-sighted friend blanked me in the street because the way I walked had changed and she didn't recognise me. She said the way I walked had been very characteristic, and now it was more normal!
I don't know what NICE are basing their recommendation on, they could conceivably be going after a cheap placebo effect.
P.S. My nice chiropractor says I have: Ilio-psoas hypertonicity secondary to Sacro-Iliac instability.
P.P.S. Careful. Chiropractors are loonies. Their explanatory theory is rubbish. My personal chiropractor is great. I would be very very suspicious of even her colleagues, let alone the rest of her profession. On the other hand, at least they are trying obvious things, to see if they work.