Gleb_Tsipursky comments on How I infiltrated the Raëlians (and was hugged by their leader) - Less Wrong Discussion
You are viewing a comment permalink. View the original post to see all comments and the full post content.
You are viewing a comment permalink. View the original post to see all comments and the full post content.
Comments (32)
Of these three, only love bombing was prominently present, but I think it was actually genuine feeling in the "low rank" members (and I've talked to quite a few). Of uniforms, I think they all had unassuming trinkets/medalions hung from their necks. Food sharing was not present and the mentioned lunch was not more special than any other lunches I went to with other groups of people.
I think there were quite a few other interesting factors at play, and that's why I suggested we could all learn something from a discussion about it. I don't have anything like a complete analysis ready myself, but I detected significant amounts of:
casual, friendly touch - there's nothing wrong with it and I would like to see more of it in other communities,
making good use of good looking people and sexual attractiveness - subtle enough to not be pretentious,
telling people to think for themselves (but I guess on meta-level, you already know the conclusion you are supposed to think of),
scripted/planned/predictable ways to evoke positive emotions,
honesty about emotions and subjective experience, and full acceptance of this by other members,
generally positive atmosphere of friendliness and helpfulness that carries over to the rest of the world, not just the in-group,
excellent stage/public speaking/PR skills of the top ranking members,
mixing in genuinely worthy/morally sound cases, like stopping wars (but from LW point of view it looks mostly like cheering than taking action).
Yup, agreed on the benefit of expressing strong positive emotions toward rank-and-file EA members, I wrote about this earlier, don't know if you saw this piece: http://lesswrong.com/lw/n7b/celebrating_all_who_are_in_effective_altruism/
Intentional Insights is actually working actively on a project of making the EA movement more welcoming, let me know if you are interested in collaborating on this project.