torekp comments on Conflicts Between Mental Subagents: Expanding Wei Dai's Master-Slave Model - LessWrong

46 Post author: Yvain 04 August 2010 09:16AM

You are viewing a comment permalink. View the original post to see all comments and the full post content.

Comments (79)

You are viewing a single comment's thread. Show more comments above.

Comment author: torekp 08 August 2010 04:52:50PM *  2 points [-]

My objection is not about unconsciousness, nor is it about consciousness - it is about the division of the mind/brain into two systems.

I'd like to expand on this point by merging it with pjeby's comment:

Remember: it isn't conscious (not an agent), and it's not singular (not an agent).

There's nothing wrong, per se, with dividing the mind into conscious and unconscious, any more than any division into a category and its complement. The problem comes when the unconscious is made out to be highly parallel to the (usual picture of the) conscious mind, including a high degree of internal coherence, capacity for sophisticated goal-seeking, etc.

Additional problems may come from viewing the conscious mind as having a single coherent focus ("it's the PR department"). The conscious mind comes across as too homunculized. Tim Tyler's view makes more sense to me: PR is one function among many.