Again, please don't read this as a personal attack.

I'm not, and I appreciate that you're being explicit that it isn't.

It's possible that, rather than failing to see that this post doesn't meet the standard of sound argument, other voters are not holding it to that standard. I don't feel qualified to judge whether that's appropriate or correct in this community, nor indeed whether it's occurring; I'm just proposing an alternative hypothesis to explain what you're observing. Hopefully one of the voters in question will weigh in.