Grognor comments on Poll results: LW probably doesn't cause akrasia - LessWrong

47 Post author: AnnaSalamon 16 November 2011 06:03PM

You are viewing a comment permalink. View the original post to see all comments and the full post content.

Comments (104)

You are viewing a single comment's thread.

Comment author: Grognor 16 November 2011 02:20:59PM 13 points [-]

I would have suggested, and still do suggest if another poll will happen, the question,

How many tabs do you have open in your browser right now?

to see if that correlates with e.g. procrastination. Large any-given-moment tab count, I hypothesize, correlates negatively with focus, and maybe slightly negatively with conscientiousness.

Comment author: Raemon 16 November 2011 06:26:03PM 2 points [-]

I open lots of tabs, then close them. I am pretty sure I have an internet addiction.

Comment author: bcoburn 17 November 2011 03:10:35AM 1 point [-]

it's not quite trivial to actually measure, but total tabs opened in the last, say, hour is probably a better measurement than how many you have open right now.

After writing that I started thinking "maybe a large number of tabs open with a slow turnover/new tabs opening rate doesn't even correlate at all with procrastination", but I suspect that's just me coming up with excuses for things and isn't actually true. Could try measuring both if the survey actually works, shrug.

Comment author: JenniferRM 17 November 2011 05:13:29AM *  2 points [-]

I generally have lots of tabs open (to the point of being made fun of) and my tendency is to open and close them swiftly in the course of multi-pronged subject exploration, with a small handful of "best of exploration" that I retain so that they prime me in subsequent hours or days or weeks with reminders, re-reading opportunities, and the possibility of being folded into longer term projects. Every so often I clean them up by transcribing URLs and notes into text files that accumulate in an idea-archive. I endorse some of this behavior, but suspect that it could become problematic in the long term... not because of "akrasia", but as part of a more specific problem called "hoarding".

Hoarding appears to be a mental disorder that can start in one's teens, but really starts to become visible in one's 30's or 40's, growing with time until you're an 80-year-old living in a pile of useless trash. My current working model for it is that retention behavior is the default behavior, mostly driven by positive emotions triggered by objects. To throw something away, a hoarder needs to consciously override this default using fluid intelligence (calculating that expected use-value in realistic plans are less than inventory costs?). As aging progresses, fluid mental abilities decline, and you're less able to decide that something isn't worth keeping, until there are tiny trails between the bed, the toilette, and the microwave and the rest of the house is full of piles of boxes full of sorted boxes of crap.

Amusingly, I found out about hoarding via my tab-heavy information searches and left the tabs open for days, and cleaned them up into a TODO file to have a conversation with family about hoarding, which is part of why I'm aware of this. Within five years I plan to do some debugging of space management habits and policies to make sure they're solid and clean, but I expect it to take 30 minutes per day of thinking, acting, measuring, and updating for around six months and it isn't that high a priority relative to other things currently on my plate.

Comment author: taryneast 17 November 2011 02:39:45PM 1 point [-]

I find that regular house moves drastically improves hoarding behaviour. Especially international moves :) It doesn't stop you hoarding - but gives you good opportunity to prune/discard.

Comment author: AnnaSalamon 16 November 2011 06:34:48PM 1 point [-]

A survey could also ask how many hours you spend online each day.

Comment author: thomblake 16 November 2011 07:10:24PM 2 points [-]

A survey could also ask how many hours you spend online each day.

I never know how to respond to this question. Do I count device-hours? Only time when information is transferring via the Internet to some device I own? Only when I ask it to? Do I need to be looking at a screen? If so, then printouts of ffdn don't count? What about programs I've downloaded and then are running offline? (&c.)

Comment author: taryneast 17 November 2011 02:40:26PM 1 point [-]

Except you'd have to exclude IT workers (especially web developers). :)

Comment author: rhollerith_dot_com 17 November 2011 10:13:55AM *  1 point [-]

That's probably not the best question to ask people.

One of the effects of my recent switch from Firefox to Google Chrome is that I came to keep much fewer (less than one third as many) tabs open. When I used the back button or the history menu in Firefox to revisit a page I had recently visited, sometimes (not always, but sometimes) the operation took a long time. I had subconsciously changed my behavior to avoid this delay by opening more new tabs. (Or maybe the change in behavior was conscious, but I forgot about it. Point is that I did not realize why I was opening a lot of new tabs until someone brought it up in conversation.) The reason opening a page in a new tab helps is that switching from the new tab back to an old tab does not incur the delay.

Although someone claims Firefox has a solution for the problem most readers are probably using a version of Firefox that still has the problem. (Versions 3 through 7 have it in my experience.) Moreover, I do not particularly believe that the problem was really fixed and that it will stay fixed.

So what should we ask instead of how many tabs the person has open? Firefox and Google Chrome both keep a record or list, which can be accessed through the History menu, of every web page visited, and this list is divided into 24-hour periods. So we might ask the person to go through the last complete 24-hour period on the list (i.e., yesterday) and count how many procrastination web pages the person visited.

Comment author: Grognor 17 November 2011 10:20:26AM -1 points [-]

People weight their identities more than they epistemically should.

You can come up with all kinds of excuses for how and why your current tab count is X, but at the end of the day, what really matters is how well the number predicts focus, conscientiousness, akrasia, etc.

Comment author: rhollerith_dot_com 18 November 2011 08:58:32AM 0 points [-]

Your reply to my attempt to inform makes me sad.

Comment author: [deleted] 16 November 2011 05:51:12PM 1 point [-]

I have ten tabs open right now.

<making excuses>This is probably because of my habit to opening almost all links in a new tab (because it's easier to get back to where I came from) and can't be bothered to close a tab unless I really have too many tabs open.</making excuses>

Comment author: lavalamp 16 November 2011 06:24:49PM 3 points [-]

I have ten tabs open right now... in my second browser window. And another 42 in the first one...

Comment author: nitePhyyre 17 November 2011 02:54:14PM 1 point [-]

112 in 5 windows.

Comment author: ata 22 November 2011 04:23:18AM 2 points [-]

I regularly let tabs proliferate until I have a dozen windows open and hundreds of tabs between them and the browser gets so slow that I have to restart it or it just crashes. When this happens, I usually don't feel like waiting for hundreds of tabs to reload, so I move the saved browser session aside, telling myself I'm just making a "temporary" new session, and then the same thing happens and I never revisit any of my past sessions. I have browser session files dating back to… 2007? That can't be right, this has been going on for way longer than that… maybe I have the older ones on a backup somewhere.

Anyway, I think I have a problem.

Comment author: dbaupp 18 November 2011 02:15:20AM 0 points [-]

o_O

Comment author: [deleted] 17 November 2011 04:50:15PM 0 points [-]

16 in one window.

Comment author: Dorikka 17 November 2011 02:17:43AM *  0 points [-]

Jawdrop. 42? Wow.

As for myself, I have 8.

Comment author: Kaj_Sotala 17 November 2011 05:49:02AM 0 points [-]

14 in two different windows.

Comment author: Bongo 22 November 2011 01:59:37AM 0 points [-]

73 tabs, 4 windows.

Comment author: Kevin 22 November 2011 03:01:41AM 0 points [-]

15 tabs

Comment author: Craig_Heldreth 17 November 2011 03:48:53PM 0 points [-]

5 tabs. Three of them are related to the Akrasia poll and I will be closing them within 5 minutes. I do not like large numbers of open tabs.