Ghatanathoah comments on An attempt to dissolve subjective expectation and personal identity - LessWrong
You are viewing a comment permalink. View the original post to see all comments and the full post content.
You are viewing a comment permalink. View the original post to see all comments and the full post content.
Comments (68)
I agree with your general line of reasoning, but I'd like to go a little more in depth. I think that personal identity is more than memory traces. What I consider part of "me" includes (but is not necessarily limited to):
-My personality
-My terminal values
-My memories
-My quirks and idiosyncrasies
"I" am aware that in the future "I" am going to change in certain ways. My utility function includes a list of changes that are desirable and undesirable, that correspond to "personal identity." Desirable changes include (but are not limited to):
-Changes that make me better at pursuing my values, such as learning new skills.
-Changes that add new positive memories to the memories I have
-Changes that cause me to have positive experiences.
Undesirable changes include: -Changes that radically alter my terminal values
-Changes that make me worse at pursuing my values.
-Amnesia, and lesser forms of memory loss.
-Changes that cause me to have negative experiences.
As you said, I exhibit "self-love," I want to make sure that the person I change into has changed in desirable ways, not undesirable ones. I want the person I turn into to be happy and have positive experiences, although I also recognize that not all my values can be reduced down to the desire to be happy or have positive experiences.
Lastly, let me say that this steel-manned conception of personal identity is a wonderful thing. It's good to have lots of distinct individuals, and that I believe the world would be a poorer place without personal identity.