TheOtherDave comments on Don't Get Offended - LessWrong

32 Post author: katydee 07 March 2013 02:11AM

You are viewing a comment permalink. View the original post to see all comments and the full post content.

Comments (588)

You are viewing a single comment's thread. Show more comments above.

Comment author: TheOtherDave 22 March 2013 02:48:54PM 2 points [-]

Just to make sure I understand your claim: as I understand it, you would predict that if we raised the people I'm referring to in an environment where "Jews are stupid" was (perhaps artificially) a prevailing social belief, they would tend to reject that belief as they came to observe Jews, because their system Is would find that belief implausible, because Jews are not in fact stupid (relative to people-like-them, as a class). But if we raised them in an environment where "blacks are stupid" was a prevailing social belief, they would not tend to reject that belief as they came to observe blacks, because their system Is would find that belief plausible, because blacks are in fact stupid (relative to people-like-them, as a class).

Yes?

Would you also expect that if we raised them in an environment where "Jews are evil" was a prevailing social belief, they would not reject that belief as they came to observe Jews, because their system Is would find that belief plausible, because Jews are in fact evil (relative to people-like-them, as a class)? Or does the principle not generalize like that?

Comment author: Eugine_Nier 23 March 2013 09:51:27PM 4 points [-]

This is basically correct.

As for Jews, I'm not sure they know many Jews, but they've probably noticed that a lot of Jews are in high positions in Academia, Finance and Politics. This is inconsistent with them being stupid but not with them being evil.

Comment author: [deleted] 23 March 2013 11:35:10PM 1 point [-]

they've probably noticed that a lot of Jews are in high positions in Academia, Finance and Politics. This is inconsistent with them being stupid

For all that such people know, Jews might be conspiring to help each other into high positions even though they aren't unusually smart compared to gentiles.

Comment author: Eugine_Nier 25 March 2013 12:06:24AM 4 points [-]

What you describe is more or less the standard negative stereotype of Jews (basically being Slytherines), and in any case what you describe is closer to the common notion of 'evil' than 'stupid'.