jazmt comments on Very Basic Model Theory - LessWrong
You are viewing a comment permalink. View the original post to see all comments and the full post content.
You are viewing a comment permalink. View the original post to see all comments and the full post content.
Comments (15)
Which of the 3 would you recommend? Does someone know why MIRI recommends Chang and Keisler if it is somewhat outdated?
Marker is the closest to the state of the art. Hodges is a bit verbose and for beginners. Poizat is a little idiosyncratic (just look at the Introduction!).
I am also interested in the basis of MIRI's recommendation. Perhaps they are not too connected to actual mathematicians studying it, as model theory is pretty much a fringe topic.
Here is the last paragraph, which you can read via Google Books:
The first paragraph of the preface to the English translation (which I found via Amazon's "look inside" feature) says this:
which sounds extremely weird until it transpires that he means it was written in French. (It appears that the book was less well received than the author hoped, at least partly on account of its having been written in French, and he is still cross about it, which I think is why he expresses himself in such a peculiar way: he's both parodying and criticizing the idea that there's something obscure about French.)
So, yeah, "idiosyncratic" is right. As for the mathematical approach, here's another quotation from the Introduction:
(Gosh!)
Why not link to the books or give their ISBNs or something?
There are at least two books on model theory by Hodges: ISBN:9780521587136 and ISBN:9780511551574