TrE comments on The Truth and Instrumental Rationality - LessWrong

11 Post author: the-citizen 01 November 2014 11:05AM

You are viewing a comment permalink. View the original post to see all comments and the full post content.

Comments (30)

You are viewing a single comment's thread.

Comment author: TrE 01 November 2014 04:53:03PM 2 points [-]

I'm happy that you adressed this topic. It adresses a certain failure mode about instrumental rationality that may commonly cause high-status people to make poor decisions.

However, I don't think your narrative about human civilization, the birth of politics etc. is actually necessary for your conclusion. I think at best it's dubious as far as historical accuracy goes, and entertaining as a metaphor for the different layers for human interaction with each other and the environment.

The example with the persons' heads, I found much more helpful at understanding your conclusion (which I share in general). It's a good post. If I could suggest a change, I would cut out the social evolution bit and fill it with more examples, counter-examples, and border cases, preferrably taken from the real world.

Comment author: the-citizen 03 November 2014 05:11:02AM 2 points [-]

Thanks for the useful suggestion. This appears to emerging as a consensus. I'll probably either tidy up the second section or cut it when I have time.