Comment author: DanArmak 25 February 2015 08:39:23PM 0 points [-]

But how is that different from ending up in Hermione's body via Horcrux?

Comment author: Alsadius 25 February 2015 08:56:45PM 0 points [-]

It allows for honesty in Parseltongue when hinting at his plan earlier.

Comment author: SolveIt 25 February 2015 07:42:20PM 1 point [-]

How to resurrect Hermione when he gets around to it. After all, she has to become an alicorn princess!

Comment author: Alsadius 25 February 2015 08:48:18PM 1 point [-]

I suspect I'm spoiling the in-joke here, but is that a literal in-story thing, or just a fan joke? Honestly, it's getting hard to tell sometimes.

Comment author: DanArmak 25 February 2015 07:14:20PM *  7 points [-]

Voldemort would not have given the properties to his body before now, because he had not had the Stone, and without its permanence effect, after a few hours the transferred properties would wear off.

He was overconfident in giving them to Hermione now, instead of to himself.

Comment author: Alsadius 25 February 2015 08:45:53PM 2 points [-]

Hermione needed them immediately, due to fears of Transfiguration sickness. Voldemort did not.

Comment author: DanielLC 25 February 2015 07:57:35PM 0 points [-]

If Voldemort just gave Hermione a horcrux, how does he plan on killing her and using her for a horcrux.

Comment author: Alsadius 25 February 2015 08:44:31PM 0 points [-]

He presumably planned on killing Harry, or just Apparating somewhere and killing a random person.

Comment author: Phigment 25 February 2015 07:24:07PM *  5 points [-]

This is a completely excellent suggestion.

Dumbledore, knowing that Harry was an expected pawn in Voldemort's plans, just booby-traps all the personal possessions that Voldemort would logically want to deprive Harry of, like the cloak, his wand, his pouch, his time-turner, Hermione's corpse...

In the same vein, booby-trap the Philosopher's stone. Coat it in a fine layer of contact poison, so that anyone who managed to retrieve it from the mirror and handled it with bare skin would get whammied. Then, if you actually win, wear gloves.

Comment author: Alsadius 25 February 2015 08:43:49PM 0 points [-]

Is poison really a good attack against someone who holds the Philosopher's Stone?

Comment author: buybuydandavis 24 February 2015 09:48:11PM *  0 points [-]

So what was the source of the resonance between Harry and Q?

Did I miss it?

I always assumed it was ritual magic, as arranged by Dumbledore and Lily, and performed by Lily.

But:

“James and Lily would have gone willingly to the death, if they had known.”

Which seems to imply that they hadn't known.

But it seems just way too convenient for Lily to just happen to fulfill the terms of a ritual, and it's unclear that V would have violated the terms by imposing his horcrux on Harry anyway.

At one time, I wondered if Harry was a time turned version of V, and that was the source of the resonance.

So what was the source of the resonance between Harry and Q? I went back to read the "while potion making" talk, but the source of the resonance seems to have been glossed over.

Comment author: Alsadius 24 February 2015 11:52:35PM 0 points [-]

Presumably that they're equal but opposite.

Comment author: jaime2000 24 February 2015 08:59:13PM *  15 points [-]

After reading comments in /r/hpmor, I've realized that Professor Quirrell has a superior move in the previous chapter, which has hopefully updated or will update soon.

Be honest, Eliezer; you just got sick of all the naked Harry jokes.

How I laughed when I realised it! When I saw you had made a Good Voldemort to oppose the evil one - ah, how I laughed!

I guess now we know what Dumbledore was laughing about in chapter 17.

The Cloak of Invisibility was torn away from him, and the shimmering black Cloak flew away from him, through the air.

Professor Quirrell caught it, and swiftly drew it over himself; in less than a second he had pulled down the Cloak's hood over his head, and disappeared.

Quirrell can escape the trap because he is no longer reflected in the mirror, being hidden by the True Cloak of Invisibility. All he has to do is walk out of the reflection, which he did.

Into the hand of the Albus Dumbledore flew from his sleeve his long, dark-grey wand, and in his other hand, as though from nowhere, appeared a short rod of dark stone.

Albus Dumbledore threw these both violently aside, just as the building sense of power rose to an unbearable peak, and then disappeared.

The Mirror returned to showing the ordinary reflection of a gold-lit room of white stone, without any trace of where Albus Dumbledore had been.

After reading Reddit, my interpretation of this scene is that Dumbledore realized Quirrellmort would not be affected by the trap, and that the only result would be that Harry would be trapped eternally outside of Time. Dumbledore makes a split-second decision to sacrifice himself in order to save the boy, throws the Elder Wand and the Line of Merlin Unbroken out of the mirror's reflection so that they will not be trapped with the headmaster, and trades places with Harry just before the Process of the Timeless (the rising sense of power) finishes. Albus Dumbledore is now trapped inside the mirror forever, and Harry Potter is back in the real room with Professor Quirrell.

Comment author: Alsadius 24 February 2015 11:51:42PM 4 points [-]

Worth noting - it is immediately after that laughter that he gives over his father's rock. And given that this chapter comments on how Dumbledore has access to wacky divination, that rock starts to make a heck of a lot more sense. (I mean, we always knew it's be an Important Quest Item, but this does shed a bit of light on why)

Comment author: polymathwannabe 21 February 2015 12:21:19AM -1 points [-]

How about a bullet? Make things appear like someone was the victim of an attempted murder, and have them "survive" with your identity hidden in them.

Comment author: Alsadius 21 February 2015 03:22:43PM 0 points [-]

Too time-sensitive, I suspect.

Comment author: Nornagest 20 February 2015 11:43:10PM *  8 points [-]

Clever idea, but currency doesn't stay long in circulation. Coins longer than bills -- the oldest bill in my wallet is from 2006, while I found a quarter from 1976 in my pocket. And if horcruces are as hard to destroy here as they are in canon, I imagine even Muggles would find it curious if a 50p coin were found intact after it should have been melted down.

I suppose it'd work if you're planning to keep supplies up on an ongoing basis and didn't think much of Muggle investigative abilities or their ability to interface with wizarding authorities, though -- and the latter does seem minimal in this universe.

How about the doorknob on the men's room in St. Paul's Cathedral? Or some other building you wouldn't expect to go away for a while. Or, heh, the Blarney Stone, if you can find enough time alone with it.

Comment author: Alsadius 21 February 2015 03:22:11PM 3 points [-]

Both are withdrawn from circulation as they decay, and if they don't decay they'll stick around for a while. As it gets old enough, it'll get picked up by a collector of some sort, who will keep it better-preserved and think nothing of its long lifespan. (This does, however, limit the amount of possessing it can do)

Better idea: Door handles.

Comment author: Squark 21 February 2015 02:03:50PM 1 point [-]

From chapter 107:

"Life-eaterss cannot desstroy me, I think," hissed Professor Quirrell. "And I will ssimply abandon thiss body if they approach too closse.

Comment author: Alsadius 21 February 2015 03:17:43PM *  0 points [-]

Good call - I only double-checked 108. That makes my theory far less likely.

View more: Prev | Next