Comment author: gwern 10 April 2012 01:11:57AM 0 points [-]

Maybe he got it from you? I know I sure didn't consider it likely enough to be worth recording.

Comment author: Anubhav 10 April 2012 06:41:22AM 0 points [-]

Maybe he got it from you?

That is correct.

Comment author: see 30 March 2012 03:43:35AM 6 points [-]

Surely Quirrelmort wouldn't give Harry that diary, right?

I thought it was fairly obviously that diary, and thus an effort by Quirrelmort to take over/destroy Harry the way Ginny was (almost) in canon. Harry has apparently avoided the trap entirely because he is under the logically reasonable impression that he needs to learn Latin to read Roger Bacon's diary. I'm pretty sure other people have reached the same conclusion in previous threads.

We then see a second effort to approximately the same end with the Dementor brought on school grounds (at Quirrelmort's instigation) with Harry's wand "accidentally" being left near the cage.

Comment author: Anubhav 31 March 2012 02:32:08AM 4 points [-]

Jbeq bs Tbq fnlf bgurejvfr. (Pgey-S 'rnegu-funggrevat')

Comment author: Xachariah 30 March 2012 10:58:44PM *  2 points [-]

You would think that Harry, on hearing a mysterious voice, would mention something. Harry turned around expecting McGonagall, not expecting some random person. Harry heard McGonagall.

The author would also mention that the voice changed owners or sounded strange. It's clever writing to drop clues in plain sight to the reader. It's not clever writing for your story to omit sensory experiences that are immediately apparent to all the involved characters, but are not conveyed to the reader.

Comment author: Anubhav 31 March 2012 02:20:31AM 2 points [-]

I would be very surprised if there were a grand total of 0 voice-changing charms in existence.

And besides, it's a whisper. That's probably significant in some way.

Comment author: Alsadius 29 March 2012 08:14:16AM *  5 points [-]

"Squib" is a nonmagical child of magical parents, at least in canon. MoR seems to be using it as a genetic marker, which I'm honestly not sure is compatible with canon.

(Now that I think about it, if Harry's genetic theory is correct, doesn't a squib child of a wizarding couple imply that Mom was getting some on the side?)

Comment author: Anubhav 29 March 2012 01:04:20PM 1 point [-]

doesn't a squib child of a wizarding couple imply that Mom was getting some on the side?

Accurate deduction! Here, have a cookie.

Comment author: Alsadius 29 March 2012 08:28:17AM 6 points [-]

IMO, new thread for Ch 82, not before - the "show all" button is still here, and the thread proliferation is getting silly, this is the third in a week. Alternately, can we get better forum software?

Comment author: Anubhav 29 March 2012 01:01:59PM 4 points [-]

Seconded. 2 threads in 3 days = BAD IDEA.

(Not that these comments will make a difference; someone or the other's gonna notice the comment-count and instinctively think "Over 500!! Ah, there's my chance to be of service! ...<one copy-paste later>... HEY GUYS NEW THREAD HERE!")

Comment author: Xachariah 29 March 2012 05:21:37AM *  13 points [-]

I would actually suspect parents of a half blood (is there a name for this?) would be the weak link, rather than muggle-born children.

You've got people who have lived their whole lives as muggles, then suddenly they fall in love and get married and find out their spouse is a wizard. They've spent ~20 years in the muggle world and probably have a career of their own. No way they don't ask their spouse to spend a couple hours and let them both live like kings for the rest of their lives. And if they don't even get that much information about their other's life, that's some seriously messed up power dynamics in that household.

Comment author: Anubhav 29 March 2012 07:46:07AM *  0 points [-]

Pop quiz: What percentage of Muggles have ever heard the word "arbitrage"?

(Retracted because reply makes sense)

Comment author: pedanterrific 28 March 2012 09:04:40PM *  8 points [-]

So, Dementors Part Deux.

First, because someone had to say it:

Harry took all the silver emotion that fueled his Patronus Charm and shoved it at the Dementor; and expected Death's shadow to flee from him -

-and as Harry did that, he flung his hands up and shouted "BOO!"

The void retreated sharply away from Harry until it came up against the dark stone behind.

In the hall there was a deathly silence.

...And to everyone but Harry, that deathly silence seemed to say "Please do not punish this one, my Dark Liege!"

Harry turned his back on the empty void, and had a moment to wonder why Dumbledore and Lucius were making such odd faces before the Aurors acted on reflex.

(I guess Dementors aren't that smart.)

Secondly, I noticed that Harry's first Transfiguration lesson includes a photograph of a Dementor. What would that look like? What does Harry see, compared to everyone else? Why was he asking all the other students what they saw in the Patronus lesson without ever once thinking of that photograph?

Comment author: Anubhav 29 March 2012 02:57:36AM 3 points [-]

Secondly, I noticed that Harry's first Transfiguration lesson includes a photograph of a Dementor. What would that look like?

Probably just a cloaked and hooded figure.

Next you'll be wondering why the robes in the picture don't decay.

Comment author: ajuc 28 March 2012 09:28:32PM 3 points [-]

So if Hermione is vassal of Harry, and Harry is temporary vassal of Lucius, then is Hermione vassal of Lucius?

Or do the muggle medieval rule "the vassal of my vassal is not my vassal" works in magical Brittain also?

Comment author: Anubhav 29 March 2012 02:20:45AM 12 points [-]

Being in debt is probably not the same thing as being a vassal, even temporarily.

(Well, maybe... Dumbledore still hasn't told us what rights Lucius now has over Harry.)

Comment author: FAWS 28 March 2012 01:12:12PM 16 points [-]

Why does Dumbledore not give a quick Summary of the worst consequences of being in debt to Lucius Malfoy? It's hard to see how that could necessitate telling secrets that cannot be revealed in public, the laws involved should already be known. Naming a few of the "certain rights" Lucius would have shouldn't take more time than Dumbledore actually spends trying to convince Harry.

Comment author: Anubhav 28 March 2012 01:20:52PM 6 points [-]

For that matter, why didn't Dumbledore mention the Imperius debt when they were talking about debts?

Dumbledore's being awfully incompetent... Wonder why that would be.

Comment author: Blueberry 28 March 2012 11:00:10AM 10 points [-]

I love Chapter 81, but it would have been way better if Draco was the one accused of murder, so Harry could marry Draco.

Comment author: Anubhav 28 March 2012 01:00:36PM 6 points [-]

He didn't marry Hermione.

View more: Prev | Next