In response to comment by [deleted] on Bargaining and Auctions
Comment author: tgb 15 July 2012 06:50:31PM 6 points [-]

Agreed - a better hypothetical might be "Suppose an antique dealer has a table which he knows he can sell for $50 to another buyer [...] The dealer should never sell for less than $50."

Comment author: Biater 15 July 2012 11:34:13PM 0 points [-]

| The dealer should never sell for less than $50, and I should never buy for more than $400, but any value in between would benefit both of us. |

The range is not wrong from just the dealer's perspective. If the exact same table is on sale at the store next door for $10, then the buyer is still making a poor decision buying it for $50 with the first dealer. Of course, if we are talking that in this bargaining game, there is only one seller of tables in the world, and only one buyers, I guess this does not apply.

Of course, maybe the buyer would be better off rethinking how much he values the classiness a new table would bring to his dining room.

Comment author: Nominull 01 December 2011 02:15:56AM 2 points [-]

you can trade money for goodness of instruction by e.g. hiring tutors

Comment author: Biater 01 December 2011 04:02:15AM 0 points [-]

Only if you are wise enough to know that, and wise enough to tell a good tutor from a poor one