Comment author: BT_Uytya 25 July 2013 05:52:51PM 0 points [-]

1) Research wandless magic

2) Become a cat Animagus

3) Cast a True Patronus Charm while in a cat form

4) Awesome, now you can impersonate Patronus of McGonnagal and no members of Order of Phoenix can trust each other anymore!

5) Ask an Auror friend to destroy your Animagus form.

6) Become a spider Animagus

7) ???

8) Terrify people!

Comment author: BlindIdiotPoster 25 July 2013 07:45:34PM 2 points [-]

For this to work a wizard would need to be able to choose what Animagus form to take.

Comment author: kilobug 25 July 2013 07:07:27PM 4 points [-]

If wizards believed animals had souls :

  1. They would have had a different reaction in chapter 48 when Harry became a vegetarian after learning about parselmouth.

  2. It would have been hinted in a way or another in the Prentending to be Wise arc, or otherwise in all the debate between Harry and other wizards about if soul exists.

  3. In chapter 47 Draco wouldn't have be saying so seriously that muggles don't have souls.

That's not very strong evidence, I admit. But taken those 3 pieces of evidence, combined with the lack of any evidence pointing in the wide belief that animals have souls, it seems reasonable to assume the common belief among wizards is that animals don't have souls.

So it seems Quirrel and Moody are contradicting each other on how the Killing Curse actually works.

Comment author: BlindIdiotPoster 25 July 2013 07:40:45PM 2 points [-]

They would have had a different reaction in chapter 48 when Harry became a vegetarian after learning about parselmouth.

I believe that animals have brains, different from human brains mostly only in intelligence. and am not a vegetarian. Wizards probably think of muggles as having souls, and have been known in cannon to hunt them for sport. Slave masters definitely though of their slaves as having souls.

It would have been hinted in a way or another in the Prentending to be Wise arc, or otherwise in all the debate between Harry and other wizards about if soul exists.

Why do you think this?

In chapter 47 Draco wouldn't have be saying so seriously that muggles don't have souls.

Touche. Draco is still an 11 year old put on the spot, so this is weak evidence.

Comment author: kilobug 25 July 2013 05:58:28PM 1 point [-]

The way I see Harry defeating death is more in the shape of casting a spell similar to Merlin's Interdict, a global enchantment, that saves the data that makes someone this person whenever a consciousness is terminated, and respawn it in a functional body. Such kind of global spell definitely can rely on high-level concepts such as "consciousness" or "self-awareness", exactly like the Interdict of Merlin relies on similar high-level concepts.

And where to draw the line for animals an implementation details, that is relevant in what Harry "should" do, but not in the core idea.

It also seems that magic already contains similar distinction in the AK spell, which doesn't seem to affect animals in MOR, and in the way only humans can create ghosts.

Comment author: BlindIdiotPoster 25 July 2013 07:35:28PM 3 points [-]

What gave you the impression that AK didn't affect animals?

Doesn't QM go on for a while about how it allows a wizard to kill any threat other than a dementor?

Comment author: Velorien 25 July 2013 04:07:59PM 0 points [-]

Death, who exists in as a semi-sentient semi-being in HPMoR.

Evidence, please?

On a related note… What happened to the tattered cloak left by the Dementor in Chapter 45? May there be two True Cloaks of Invisibility?

Since Dementor cloaks don't appear to keep Dementors invisible in any way, this seems a bit of a leap.

Comment author: BlindIdiotPoster 25 July 2013 07:24:05PM 3 points [-]

Evidence would be the existence of Dementors, which are personifications of death and may or may not be semi-sentient.

Comment author: Kindly 25 July 2013 03:02:35PM *  4 points [-]

It's a fairly literal translation. I think the most likely option is that the Potter motto was first taken from the Bible in Latin, and at some point after the completion of the King James Bible (in the 1600s) the motto was updated to English.

The Peverells were, after all, contemporaries of Godric Gryffindor (at least in the HPMoR universe), so they would've been all over the Latin mottoes.

Comment author: BlindIdiotPoster 25 July 2013 07:21:24PM 1 point [-]

I was actually under the impression that the Perverells lived before Merlin.

Comment author: Pfft 24 July 2013 09:22:44PM 5 points [-]

Have you read Blindsight? It explicitly mentions this idea, and is generally very nice.

Comment author: BlindIdiotPoster 25 July 2013 05:39:43PM 1 point [-]

If by "nice" you mean "a good book" then I agree.

In response to comment by [deleted] on Open thread, July 23-29, 2013
Comment author: pengvado 25 July 2013 01:16:18AM *  1 point [-]

Is there a benefit from doing that server-side rather than client-side? I've long since configured my web browser to always use my favorite font rather than whatever is suggested by any website.

Comment author: BlindIdiotPoster 25 July 2013 05:36:09PM 0 points [-]

I'm going to agree with this post. Maybe an option to make everything appear in a preferred font would be useful, if the programmers aren't busy with anything else.

Comment author: Oligopsony 24 July 2013 09:37:35PM 3 points [-]

Can Blindsight-style Scramblers employ anthropic reasoning?

Comment author: BlindIdiotPoster 25 July 2013 05:33:26PM 2 points [-]

To the extent that anthropic reasoning works at all, it doesn't seem like sentience should be needed.

To use an analogy, it seems to me that this non-sentient site is sort of using anthropic reasoning.

Comment author: Rukifellth 23 July 2013 02:32:34AM 0 points [-]

Is marginal utility one term or two?

Comment author: BlindIdiotPoster 23 July 2013 04:52:29PM 0 points [-]

I don't understand the question.

Comment author: BlindIdiotPoster 23 July 2013 04:41:14PM 6 points [-]

Does anyone here think a Phoenix Wright style game could be useful as a medium for Rationalist fiction?

View more: Prev | Next