Comment author: OrphanWilde 26 June 2015 02:34:10PM 2 points [-]

From that perspective, your non-profit could be creating the illusion of progress - helping raise the people you work with in belize out of poverty, while simultaneously taking jobs from other, poverty stricken people in EG india.

The nature of wage markets means the jobs would tend to go to the worst-off people who can take the jobs, whose wage demands would be lowest, as they'd have the most to gain from a given wage (that is, they'd take the job for less money, because the money is more valuable to them). This isn't a bad thing, although it's usually presented as one, particularly by those whose wages would be undercut.

(This doesn't consider market barriers or interference, granted; for one example, a mountain village might have the most to gain, but be unable to offer competitive labor pricing owing to the cost of providing infrastructure.)

Comment author: Brendon_Wong 30 June 2015 09:02:26AM 0 points [-]

Belizeans would probably be competing with wealthier people for work because their high level of English mastery allows them to compete for more advanced positions. The websites I mentioned have many workers from more developed countries. For example, half of MTurk's users are from the United States.

Comment author: [deleted] 26 June 2015 05:22:00AM 3 points [-]

There's definitely a market there - as you clearly are aware (from mentioning upwork) there's a booming market in these types of remote work arbitrage opportunities.

I'm curious what you expect your value to be over and above what these online freelance companies are already doing. Is your non-profit's goal essentially to be marketers for these companies, letting people in less advantaged countries know that these opportunities exist?

The next question would be - how well are these companies ALREADY attracting poverty stricken people. Every person I've hired from upwork, when I asked them how they got into it, specifically mentioned trying to alleviate their own poverty. From that perspective, your non-profit could be creating the illusion of progress - helping raise the people you work with in belize out of poverty, while simultaneously taking jobs from other, poverty stricken people in EG india.

Comment author: Brendon_Wong 30 June 2015 08:59:50AM 0 points [-]

Many people in developing countries do not have access to the technology needed to participate in virtual employment, so we will provide computer and internet access. We will be doing marketing in a way, yes, although it is guidance and training as well. In the future, we will move on from guiding people through using third party systems to directly selling virtual employment services, which should be much more profitable.

Comment author: Strangeattractor 26 June 2015 08:36:03AM 8 points [-]

I think it would be helpful to ask more people in Belize what they think. Too often things are driven by what donors think, not by what would be good for the people a project is ostensibly trying to help.

Also, perhaps run a small-scale pilot project, then learn from that.

Comment author: Brendon_Wong 30 June 2015 08:56:29AM 1 point [-]

Thank you for your suggestions. I have in fact surveyed people and organizations in Belize. The general consensus is that there are a lot of people who are unemployed or working for very low wages, and getting higher paying employment would improve their standard of living. You mentioned a small scale pilot, we have actually run many such pilots, which is how we found that it would be possible to help people earn around $3 USD an hour. We are currently working on remote testing of our program before actually sending staff to Belize.

Comment author: shminux 26 June 2015 12:33:44AM 1 point [-]

Has this been tried before elsewhere? If not, why not? If yes, what were the results?

Comment author: Brendon_Wong 26 June 2015 12:38:19AM *  0 points [-]

There is definitely no prominent implementation of this concept and its related variations. Many nonprofits offer job training and give people computer and internet access, but starting what is essentially a virtual employment company to help people is not something I have heard about before, hence this program. It is possible that this idea was not implemented before in a charitable way because people start virtual employment companies for for-profit purposes, and those companies are very successful. As to the idea of connecting the impoverished with virtual employment services, it is possible many people are not aware of virtual employment services and thus have not implemented the idea.

Comment author: Elo 26 June 2015 12:08:22AM 4 points [-]

I agree with ChristianKl. you said:

it is not expected to attract for-profit support, especially because it would probably not be a particularly profitable venture.

why won't it be profitable? Can't you make it profitable? There is a market failure connecting people in places where minimum wage is too high to employ locals with employees willing to work for less. (in that its not easy to hire an international team)

I would be interested in getting involved in a for-profit version of this idea. (and was taking small steps towards researching similar ideas)

Comment author: Brendon_Wong 26 June 2015 12:20:36AM *  0 points [-]

The venture could be profitable, yes. Would it generate massive amounts of income? That is also possible. I did not consider a for-profit version of the idea because the project itself was supposed to be charitable in nature. I am considering starting a for-profit branch of this idea, and would be open to hearing other people's ideas and motivations. Is your motivation and other's in getting involved in a for-profit implementation of this idea to earn money?

To elaborate more on profits, the initial implementation of this idea might not be incredibly profitable because we are relying on third party virtual employment services like the aforementioned upwork.com to ensure the initial implementation (this summer!) would be a success and members would be able to find guaranteed work. Directly contracting with people and organizations wanting virtual workers is expected to be a lot more profitable.

Comment author: ChristianKl 25 June 2015 11:35:57PM 5 points [-]

Why do you want to do this as a nonprofit instead of a for profit company?

Comment author: Brendon_Wong 25 June 2015 11:56:38PM *  1 point [-]

Thanks for your question! This particular project is charitable in nature and would probably require funding to get off the ground and expand more rapidly. Since it is not expected to attract for-profit support, especially because it would probably not be a particularly profitable venture, most funding would probably come from people/organizations with non-profit motives. People/organizations with non-profit motives generally only donate to nonprofits, which have a better public image and are more trusted to pursue altruistic goals like donors expect. We can also offer tax-deductible donations to donors, and we do not get taxed on donations or income, which gives us a financial advantage for attracting more donations and for earning more income. The only benefits to starting a for-profit venture I can think of would be greater freedom in compensating supporters and in our operations, but since this project is not expected to be a huge profit maker and has charitable intentions, I did not choose the for-profit path, although of course I could consider it in more detail.

Can You Give Support or Feedback for My Program to Alleviate Poverty?

10 Brendon_Wong 25 June 2015 11:18PM

Hi LessWrong,

Two years ago, when I travelled to Belize, I came up with an idea for a self-sufficient scalable program to address poverty. I saw how many people in Belize were unemployed or getting paid very low wages, but I also saw how skilled they were, a result of English being the national language and a mandatory education system. Many Belizeans have a secondary/high school education in Belize, and the vast majority have at least a primary school education and can speak English. I thought to myself, "it's too bad I can't teleport Belizeans to the United States, because in the U.S., they would automatically be able to earn many times more the minimum wage in Belize with their existing skills."

But I knew there was a way to do it: "virtual teleportation." My solution involves using computer and internet access in conjunction with training and support to connect the poor with high paying international work opportunities. My tests of virtual employment using Upwork and Amazon Mechanical Turk show that it is possible to earn at least twice the minimum wage in Belize, around $3 an hour, working with flexible hours. This solution is scalable because there is a consistent international demand for very low wage work (relatively speaking) from competent English speakers, and in other countries around the world like South Africa, many people matching that description can be found and lifted out of poverty. The solution could become self-sufficient because running a virtual employment enterprise or taking a cut of the earnings of members using virtual employment services (as bad as that sounds) can generate enough income to pay for the relatively low costs of monthly internet and the one-time costs of technology upgrades.

If you have any feedback, comments, suggestions, I would love to hear about it in the comments section. Feedback on my fundraising campaign at igg.me/at/bvep is also greatly appreciated.

If you are thinking about supporting the idea, my team and I need your help to make this possible. It may be difficult for us to reach our goal, but every contribution greatly increases the chances our fundraiser and our program will be successful, especially in the early stages. All donations are tax-deductible, and if you’d like, you can also opt-in for perks like flash drives and t-shirts. It only takes a moment to make a great difference: igg.me/at/bvep.

Thank you for reading!

Rational Healthcare

-25 Brendon_Wong 06 January 2015 06:58AM

So what is "rational healthcare?" BetterCare. BetterCare is a startup that brings healthcare sharing from Christian healthcare sharing ministries to the general public. We are also considering facilitating healthcare sharing among other circles like religious communities, local neighborhoods, or even interest-groups like rationalists. Christian healthcare sharing ministries don’t provide health insurance. Instead, they cut out the middlemen, in this case insurance companies, and let members share healthcare costs directly among themselves. The result is the equivalent of health insurance at half the price, and with low “deductibles” and full coverage of almost all conditions to boot. BetterCare can do the same for you. We can provide monthly rates at just $180 per person and $410 per family, as opposed to the U.S. national average for health insurance at $490 per person and $1363 per family per month. If you want to learn more and stay updated on our progress, check out our website and join the waitlist for new member opportunities at www.bettercare.tk.

Comment author: Sysice 12 October 2014 04:49:05PM *  2 points [-]

HPMOR is an excellent choice.

What's your audience like? A book club (presumed interest in books, but not significantly higher maturity or interest in rationality than baseline), a group of potential LW readers, some average teenagers?

The Martian (Andy Weir) would be a good choice for a book-club-level group- very entertaining to read and promotes useful values. Definitely not of the "awareness raising" genre, though.

If you think a greater than average amount of them would be interested in rationality, I'd consider spending some time on Ted Chiang's work- only short stories at the moment, but very well received, great to read, and brings up some very good points that I'd bet most of your audience hasn't considered.

Edit: Oh, also think about Speaker for the Dead.

Comment author: Brendon_Wong 12 October 2014 08:59:30PM 2 points [-]

Thank you for your help! I have edited my post with additional information. My audience is a general youth audience, think of promoting content to an entire high school, with "average teenagers" and people that might be more interested in content. Of course, some people will be more interested than others, so a wide variety of recommendations for different interest groups is better. I'm primarily looking for books that promote ethical/altruistic behavior, I'm not sure if any of your beforementioned recommendations do so.

Comment author: Manfred 12 October 2014 06:47:47PM 5 points [-]

Not sure what you mean by "positive" here. Ethically, what you probably want are works that make you take the perspectives of people different from you, and involve solving problems in creative and effective ways. Maybe I'll try making a list of those later, but right now I'm just going to focus on fiction that might inspire people's problem-solving skills a little.

Top Recommendations:

Online original fiction: Everything written by Ted Chiang (excepting "Understand," perhaps - that is not a story about ethical behavior :P). "The Man Who Bridged The Mist" by Kij Johnson. Possibly some selected Greg Egan stories, possibly Yudkowsky's The Sword of Good.

Book-form fiction: Tons of options here. Rosemary Kirstein's "The Steerswoman's Road" is quite good. Asimov's novel "The Gods Themselves" is a classic (if PG-13), can also direct them to an Asimov anthology like "I, Robot." More classics like Lloyd Alexander's The Iron Ring (one of those kids books that's still good for adults), lots of Ursula LeGuin (particularly her early stuff). Terry Pratchett (probably best to get people started with a later novel like Thief of Time, Small Gods, Wee Free Men, or Making Money).

Fanfiction: Luminosity, HPMOR, most things alexanderwales has written (all good, maybe not all what you want), and the superman fanfic Veritas are all pretty recommendable to general audiences. Another contender would be author Forthwith's My Little Pony short stories (not that their longer stuff isn't also good, it's just not finished).

Comment author: Brendon_Wong 12 October 2014 08:57:01PM 1 point [-]

Thanks for your recommendations! I've edited my post to make it more specific, I am looking for content that promotes altruistic behavior, either fiction or nonfiction.

View more: Prev | Next