LESSWRONG
LW

177
Viliam
25854Ω15962841
Message
Dialogue
Subscribe

Posts

Sorted by New

Wikitag Contributions

Comments

Sorted by
Newest
Open Thread Autumn 2025
Viliam19h20

a friend suggested I research "Roko's". [...] Would be happy to discuss.

Contrary to what Wikipedia suggests, the people who enjoy discussing this topic on Less Wrong are mostly the newcomers who arrived here after reading Wikipedia. But we have a wiki page on the topic.

We are all predisposed to think in Binary terms; either/or, black & white, good or bad, etc. [...] Almost everything is on a gradient.

Another danger is that people who want to go behind the binary, often fall into one of the following traps:

  • Unary -- "everything is unknowable", "everything is relative", etc.
  • Ternary -- there are three values: "yes", "no", and "maybe", but all the "maybe" values are the same

I am also quite comfortable discussing political or U.S constitutional issues.

That is not a frequent topic here, for reasons. Maybe ACX is a better place for that.

Reply
Open Thread Autumn 2025
Viliam19h20

would you set up the causal chain of events to one day reveal to humans that they do not have free will?

You would need to make sure that there is no misunderstanding. Otherwise you would be communicating something else than you intended.

So, considering that the debate on this topic is typically full of confusion, the answer is probably: no.

Reply
Open Thread Autumn 2025
Viliam19h20

The chain of causality that makes your heart beat mostly goes outside your consciousness. (Not perfectly, for example if you start thinking about something scary and as a consequence your heart starts beating faster, then your thought did have an impact. But you are not doing it on purpose.)

The chain of causality that determines your day-to-day decisions goes through your consciousness. I think that makes the perceived difference.

That doesn't change the fact that your consciousness is ultimately implemented on atoms which follow the laws of physics.

Reply
One Does Not Simply Walk Away from Omelas
Viliam2d40

Or do we blame [drug addicts] for having chosen a life that nobody would ever choose?

Uhm, yes? When I see teenagers in front of my window, trading stolen goods from a nearby supermarket for some dried grass, I do think they have some responsibility for what happens. Am I the asshole?

Reply
What I've Learnt About How to Sleep
Viliam2d40

Sleeping too much can tire me out as much as sleeping too little.

If I consider getting off the bed in the morning, but I feel tired, is there an easy way to figure out whether I have slept too little or too much?

Taking a nap when I return home from work is like magic: it resets my brain so that the evening feels like getting an extra piece of weekend.

Reply
Open Thread Autumn 2025
Viliam2d9-1

A crazy idea, I wonder if someone tried it: "All illegal drugs should be legal, if you buy them at a special government-managed shop, under the condition that you sign up for several months of addiction treatment."

The idea is that drug addicts get really short-sighted and willing to do anything when they miss the drug. Typically that pushes them to crime (often encouraged by the dealers: "hey, if you don't have cash, why don't you just steal something from the shop over there and bring it to me?"). We could use the same energy to push them towards treatment instead.

"Are you willing to do anything for the next dose? Nice, sign these papers and get your dose for free! As a consequence you will spend a few months locked away, but hey, you don't care about the long-term consequences now, do you?" (Ideally, the months of treatment would increase exponentially for repeated use.)

Seems to me like a win/win situation. The addict gets the drug immediately, which is all that matters to them at the moment. The public would pay for the drug use anyway, either directly, or by being victims of theft. (Or it might be possible to use confiscated drugs for this purpose.) At least this way there is no crime, and the addict is taken off the streets.

This would be especially useful in those situation where "everyone knows" the place where the drugs are being sold (because obvious addicts congregate there), but for some technical reasons it is difficult to prove it legally. Don't need to prove anything, just open a sales stand there saying "free drugs" and watch the street get clean.

Reply
17 years old, self-taught state control - looking for people who actually get this
Viliam3d42

Everyone IRL either thinks I'm crazy or doesn't understand what I'm describing.

Well, that sums up my reaction, too.

It sounds to me like you are saying that you found a way to focus your attention, and used it to get some IT skills. Cool if true. The rest of your post is less clear. You're looking for a way to figure out when you actually improve and when you are just imagining you are? Someone to talk to about that?

I think that communicating more clearly could be a good start. And maybe take MBTI less seriously, or at least not assume that everyone is familiar with obscure abbreviations of this horoscope equivalent.

Reply
Open Thread Autumn 2025
Viliam3d51

Welcome!

Reply
shortplav
Viliam3d40

the result will probably look like the DeepDream dogs, but for Helpfulness, Harmlessness and Honesty.

I wonder if humans also do similar things. I mean, they start with some relatively simple value such as "don't hurt other people" and keep applying it everywhere until they get things like "oppose euthanasia, even if people in pain are begging you" or "oppose cultural appropriation, even if that culture is actively trying to export its pieces" (sorry for mindkilling examples, but at least I got two different ones), which for the outsiders kinds seems like a DeepDream version of "not hurting people", but for the insiders it just feels perfectly consistent.

Reply
AllAmericanBreakfast's Shortform
Viliam3d31

a specific piece of information the student is immediately ready for. I want a word for such pieces of information, so let's call them useable bits.

Related concept: "zone of proximal development" = the set of all things the student is able to learn immediately.

Reply
Load More
9Viliam's Shortform
5y
238
No wikitag contributions to display.
87Halfhaven virtual blogger camp
8d
6
32Wikipedia, but written by AIs
1mo
9
36Learned helplessness about "teaching to the test"
4mo
16
27[Book Translation] Three Days in Dwarfland
5mo
6
43The first AI war will be in your computer
6mo
10
110Two hemispheres - I do not think it means what you think it means
8mo
21
26Trying to be rational for the wrong reasons
1y
9
32How unusual is the fact that there is no AI monopoly?
Q
1y
Q
15
37An anti-inductive sequence
1y
10
30Some comments on intelligence
1y
5
Load More