Comment author: cultureulterior 05 September 2013 11:24:37PM *  1 point [-]

I'm beginning to think the/a final enemy might be Dumbledore after all.

(1) Wouldn't Dumbledore, when he was invisibly following HP to the graveyard, have seen the millennia-old stone alight with prophecy?

(2) What if it was Dumbledore's troll, and Quirrel can prove it or, Dumbledore has had a troll guard and he can make it seem like this was it?

Comment author: cultureulterior 01 September 2013 10:47:52AM 0 points [-]

Does Bellatrix have a horcrux backup, and if not, why not? You'd think that if Voldemort thought enough of her importance to remove her from Azkaban, he'd have made sure to back her up beforehand?

Comment author: cultureulterior 26 August 2013 10:48:23AM 2 points [-]

What steps has Harry taken to investigate the characters of those killed by Voldemort? You'd think that he'd kill/order killed, in particular, people that he did not care to have around in his future realm, once he took power. I'm assuming that the Dark Mark comes with its own self-destruct switch, so he does not have make sure any Death Eater dies. People killed by Death Eaters in self defence do not count.

This might explain why, for example, he did not kill Dumbledore, or any of the truly awesome people in the OOTP (Moody, et al), because he knew that they would be reasonable subjects.

Comment author: Eliezer_Yudkowsky 18 August 2013 04:30:38AM 9 points [-]

Erm, he also got 40,000 Galleons.

Comment author: cultureulterior 19 August 2013 09:08:04PM -1 points [-]

But not in a particularly interesting way

Comment author: cultureulterior 16 July 2013 11:25:39PM 5 points [-]

Two points:

  • Did anyone remember to take the "42" envelope, before returning Hermione's effects to her parents?
  • Are Harry's and Hermione's parents allowed to talk to each other?
Comment author: cultureulterior 04 July 2013 06:53:38PM 12 points [-]

"Rule 8: Any technique which is good enough to defeat me once is good enough to learn myself"

Voldemort has been defeated once. What would he do, if he wanted to learn how?

Comment author: MugaSofer 24 September 2012 12:18:08PM *  1 point [-]

Chapter 77:

She and Harry had looked up Divination early on in their research; Harry had insisted that they read everything they could find about prophecies that wasn't in the Restricted Section. As Harry had observed, it would save a lot of effort if they could just get a seer to prophesy everything they would figure out thirty-five years later. (Or to put it in Harry's terms, any means of obtaining information transmitted from the distant future was potentially an instant global victory condition.)

But, as Hermione had explained to Millicent, prophesying wasn't controllable, there was no way to ask for a prophecy about anything in particular. Instead (the books had said) there was a sort of pressure that built up in Time, when some huge event was trying to happen, or stop itself from happening. And seers were like weak points that let out the pressure, when the right listener was nearby. So prophecies were only about big, important things, because only that generated enough pressure; and you almost never got more than one seer saying the same thing, because afterward the pressure was gone. And, as Hermione had further explained to Millicent, the seers themselves didn't remember their prophecies, because the message wasn't for them. And the messages would come out in riddles, and only someone who heard the prophecy in the seer's original voice would hear all the meaning that was in the riddle. There was no possible way that Millicent could just give out a prophecy any time she wanted, about school bullies, and then remember it, and if she had it would've come out as 'the skeleton is the key' and not 'Susan Bones has to be there'.

Comment author: cultureulterior 24 September 2012 10:23:02PM 0 points [-]

This does not imply that prophecies have intended recipients, though.

Comment author: MugaSofer 23 September 2012 10:22:59AM 1 point [-]

A prophecy only occurs if the intended recipient is able to hear the seer in question. Dumbledore has just found a way to be in hearing range at all times, making it less likely a third party will overhear a prophecy meant for him. Unless Voldemort regularly receives prophecies, it would be a waste of resources - you need an impenetrable prison, which is unlikely to be cheap. Of course, if he does regularly receive prophecies it would be useful, but that seems unlikely.

Comment author: cultureulterior 23 September 2012 07:08:51PM 0 points [-]

I'm not sure that's the way of it in the HPMOR universe. Consider the final chapter- who were those aborted prophecies for?

Comment author: cultureulterior 22 September 2012 04:54:21PM 0 points [-]

Why doesn't voldemort have a source of prophecies? If I were him, I'd have kidnapped a known seer, and kept them locked up inside a mountain, or something like that, and recorded their output like it seems dumbledore does. Every power he sees he tries to take for himself, etc..

Comment author: TraderJoe 21 September 2012 08:13:28AM 0 points [-]

Does anyone know why there aren't London LW meetups? I have a hard time reconciling ~8,000,000 Anglophones with no LW meetups. Have we tried them before and did they fail?

Comment author: cultureulterior 21 September 2012 10:52:21PM 0 points [-]

There was something this summer, but I missed it.

View more: Prev | Next