LESSWRONG
LW

323
Screwtape
68981795712
Message
Dialogue
Subscribe

I'm Screwtape, also known as Skyler. I'm an aspiring rationalist originally introduced to the community through HPMoR, and I stayed around because the writers here kept improving how I thought. I'm fond of the Rationality As A Martial Art metaphor, new mental tools to make my life better, and meeting people who are strange in ways I find familiar and comfortable. If you're ever in the Boston area, feel free to say hi.

Starting early in 2023, I'm the ACX Meetups Czar. You might also know me from the New York City Rationalist Megameetup, editing the Animorphs: The Reckoning podfic, or being that guy at meetups with a bright bandanna who gets really excited when people bring up indie tabletop roleplaying games. 

I recognize that last description might fit more than one person.

Sequences

Posts

Sorted by New

Wikitag Contributions

Comments

Sorted by
Newest
5Screwtape's Shortform
3y
52
Just Another Five Minutes
Screwtape2d61
  • Get better metrics on what works when teaching rationality. Talk to all the rationalist/adjacent training groups, ask what metric they think they're improving, check if graduates of each group is improving on the metrics of all the groups, control against general population and the social rationalists.
  • Once we know what works (or if someone knows something I don't about what works), start getting it taught broadly. Teach more instructors, make inroads on the education systems, backchain from "X years from now, random people on the street know how to do this." The win condition is e.g. calibration being taught in grade school at least as often as we teach arithmetic.
  • A stable, user friendly crossposter for events. It's pretty common for someone to want an event to exist on multiple of Facebook, LessWrong, Partiful, Meetup.com, a Google group mailing list, a Discord event, a Google calendar, announced in Telegram, announced in Whatsapp, announced in Instagram, etc. "Here's the time, here's the place, here's the plaintext title and the plaintext description. Realistically this would be a constant pain to maintain as APIs changed, but I do think the math pencils out.
  • The go-wide version of a rationalist conference. EAGs get above a thousand people, and I think they're the biggest events in the adjacent space. Fandom or industry conferences in the mid-four digits aren't hard to find, and there's things with five digit counts. Plausibly the juice isn't worth the squeeze here; you can't meaningfully talk to all the people at a Manifest or an EAG already. And yet DEF CON exists and afaik is considered pretty valuable by those who partake.
  • Translations of the sequences or HPMOR into other languages. Maps of rationalist activity are mostly heatmaps of English speakers, with the exception of Germany being a notable outlier. Harry Potter was pretty popular in China!
Reply21
Everyone has a plan until they get lied to the face
Screwtape2d20

Aww, that doesn't work anymore? Probably good for the world if sad for pranksters. I admit I last pulled some variant of this prank in the late aughts/early 2010s and haven't tried recently. I got an afternoon of enjoyment out of upsidedownternet.

My next best idea I'm sure I could pull off would be to make my own website that looked like the wikipedia article, pull that up on my phone, and show it to the mark.

Reply
Learning information which is full of spiders
Screwtape8d30

The second Merrin story (well, I don't know if they're chronological or what but it's the one I reference second in this post) is here.

Reply
Solstice Season 2025: Ritual Roundup & Megameetups
Screwtape8d20

New York City

When: December 20th, 6:00pm

Where: HI NYC Hostel at 891 Amsterdam Avenue, NY

Tickets: https://rationalistmegameetup.com/

This combines with the East Coast Rationalist Megameetup, a weekend of neat talks and relaxed socialization. You can totally get a ticket to just Solstice or just Megameetup if that's more your preference.

Reply
Solstice Season 2025: Ritual Roundup & Megameetups
Screwtape8d20

Boston

When: December 27th, 6:30 pm

Where: Connexion, 149 Broadway, Somerville, MA

No tickets needed, RSVPs appreciated either at https://www.facebook.com/events/1188042049854248 or https://www.lesswrong.com/events/asnjsSXqKNmfKMcB9/boston-secular-solstice-2025

Reply
The Snaw
Screwtape9d40

Oh, thanks! First two I just straight agree with.

For a Scientist checks things again and again

Hrm. "But" is better than "For." I think "Now" might be better than either, but I've been staring at these lines for a while- thoughts?

So the best of their work is the kind that’ll replicate.

Eh. I like "so the best off their work is the kind that'll replicate" over "so the best of their work is what can replicate" but admit mine isn't great.

Under sensible, responsible consideration "replicate" is just a really insane word to try and make work in anapestic tetrametre. I have to cheat my pronounciation a bit to downplay the "rep-" plus it takes some weird setup. Since I am not always a sensible responsible poet I wanted to put "replicate" in here somewhere anyway. 

"Why on Earth [should/would] we test?" said the Snaw with a sniff."

Yep, I dropped a foot, this is straightforwardly better.

Thanks for the suggestions!

Reply
The Snaw
Screwtape10d20

I'm enough of a visual artist that I could draw the scenes, but I haven't had much if any practice or training in colour. If anyone feels inspired to make better art happen somehow I'd be pretty interested in upgrading out of this, possibly for compensation if I like the style. Otherwise adding better art to this will go on my backlog.

Reply
Secular Solstice Roundup 2025
Screwtape10d30

Boston

When: December 27th, 6:30 pm

Where: Connexion, 149 Broadway, Somerville, MA

No tickets needed, RSVPs appreciated either at https://www.facebook.com/events/1188042049854248 or https://www.lesswrong.com/events/asnjsSXqKNmfKMcB9/boston-secular-solstice-2025

Reply
Halfway to Anywhere
Screwtape11d30

Feels weird to correct-vote and also give a missed the point react.

I'm aware of Tsiolkovsky's harsh equation, and I totally am treating my delta-v here as magical momentum applied from some kind of platonic spherical cow engine. I stand by my metaphor anyway. If you handwave the mass of the fuel, I think my numbers are roughly right. If you don't handwave the fuel, then all my numbers are wrong, yes in a way that makes Pluto take more effort, and handling the implications of how much more effort becomes closer to an engineering problem (e.g. "do multiple launches to bring fuel up before leaving LEO.") 

Once we're treating it as engineering problems, if you've already gone to the moon I think you've already solved the hardest engineering problems involved in going to Pluto.

Reply1
Lack of Social Grace is a Lack of Skill
Screwtape12d100

I'm worried I'm unintentionally creating a motte-and-bailey in the comments, so I'm going to try and split a few things out. Here's four things all of which I believe are true, but which people could reasonably agree or disagree with separately.

  1. It's possible to make strictly better statements in the Graceful / Honest spectrum. "You gotta tie your shoes idiot" is less graceful than "Do you know your shoe's untied?" without communicating more information about the shoe. It's even more syllables. More grace doesn't actually always mean less honest.
  2. Communicating gracefully takes effort to learn, but once learned, can be close to free on most per-statement cases. It's like learning a language; it would take me a long time to learn German, but a bilingual English and German speaker wouldn't find most conversation hard in one language.[1] 
  3. Communicating gracefully is worth effort to learn. It is better to have this skill than to not have this skill.
  4. There are instrumental circumstances where giving up some honesty is worth getting some grace, especially if the rate of exchange is favourable. (Please don't take this line as advocating for outright lies in the name of momentary preservation of social harmony. I think I'm more honest than the average person even when I'm making these trades.)

I think 4 is true, but I'm on board with LessWrong in particular being a place where we don't give up units of honesty in order to get units of grace no matter the exchange rate. I'm less cheerful about existing in spaces where we give up 1.

  1. ^

    Note: I'm not trying to say every single sentence is close to free to say in the other language, or gracefully- there's detailed German words like Schadenfreude that are harder to communicate in English, and there's it takes effort to gracefully fire someone for non-performance.

Reply
Load More
Running A Basic ____ Meetup
Cohabitive Game Design
The LessWrong Community Census
Meetup Tips
Meetup in a box
46Mixed Feelings on Social Munchkinry
1d
2
26The Control System Going Out of Control
1d
0
24Process Crimes and Pedantic Rules
1d
4
17Brand New Experience Salesman
2d
0
28Just Another Five Minutes
3d
4
149Everyone has a plan until they get lied to the face
4d
26
28Meetup Tip: Food
5d
1
24Better than Baseline
6d
1
21On Stance
7d
2
49Learning information which is full of spiders
8d
7
Load More
Meetups (specific examples)
9 months ago
(+52/-8)
Meetups (specific examples)
3 years ago
(+813)