CarlShulman comments on BHTV: Eliezer Yudkowsky & Razib Khan - Less Wrong

12 Post author: MichaelGR 06 February 2010 02:27PM

You are viewing a comment permalink. View the original post to see all comments and the full post content.

Comments (66)

You are viewing a single comment's thread. Show more comments above.

Comment author: CarlShulman 07 February 2010 12:31:18PM *  5 points [-]

The issue hasn't been switched, but Razib didn't (and usually doesn't) optimize for resistance to misinterpretation in snarky pseudo-correction comments.

Razib and Eliezer were talking about the ability to score embryos based on genomes to select for IQ. To do that, one would need to know alleles responsible for a a substantial fraction of the population variation. Genome-wide-association studies haven't found those for IQ, where they have for, e.g. skin and eye color. Rare retardation-causing alleles that collectively explain less than 1% of that variation are a sideshow for prediction of population variation, the causes of normal variation differ. So meaningful embryo selection is feasible for skin color, but not for IQ. That's not esoteric, that was the concrete point in discussion that inspired Razib to mention the state of the search for IQ alleles.