Dagon comments on A Challenge for LessWrong - Less Wrong

16 Post author: simplicio 29 June 2010 11:47PM

You are viewing a comment permalink. View the original post to see all comments and the full post content.

Comments (158)

You are viewing a single comment's thread.

Comment author: Dagon 04 July 2010 01:50:15AM 6 points [-]

Upvoted because I like the topic, however this is a very confused post. Most examples given are not rational means to any end I think I have.

I'd love to see a post explaining why you think any of these recommendations are rational.

Doing nothing (or rather, doing what I'm already doing) conserves the resources I control, allows me to make better decisions later, when I have more information, and has intrinsic value (pleasure/leisure) to me.

Comment author: simplicio 05 July 2010 05:57:17AM 0 points [-]

I agree now that it was somewhat confused.

Most examples given are not rational means to any end I think I have.

Do you mean you don't share their ends, or think they're terrible means?

Comment author: Dagon 06 July 2010 08:11:00PM 0 points [-]

I mean I can't tell from the article whether you're recommending a change in ends (and if so, based on what) or means (and if so, based on what). I don't see a path from your recommended actions to any ends that I know of and share.

Declaring the ends you're expecting me to support, and a path from your recommendation to those ends would let me give more specific critiques (or simply to join your campaign if you're right).