John_Maxwell_IV comments on Introducing Simplexity - Less Wrong

5 Post author: ArisKatsaris 15 September 2012 03:34AM

You are viewing a comment permalink. View the original post to see all comments and the full post content.

Article Navigation

Comments (30)
Tags: simplexity

Comments (30)

You are viewing a single comment's thread. Show more comments above.

Comment author: John_Maxwell_IV 12 September 2012 11:25:55PM 1 point [-]

I don't see the alien-and-pretty-woman picture as quite representative of either failure of imagination or argument from ignorance. I do think that ArisKatsaris' notion of "simplexity" is more general than these.

Comment author: shminux 12 September 2012 11:34:11PM *  1 point [-]

From Wikipedia:

Argument from incredulity/Lack of imagination

Arguments from incredulity take the form:
P is too incredible (or: I cannot imagine how P could possibly be true); therefore P must be false.
I cannot imagine how P could possibly be false; therefore P must be true.
These arguments are similar to arguments from ignorance in that they too ignore and do not properly eliminate the possibility that something can be both incredible and still be true, or appear to be obvious and yet still be false.

Specifically, "I cannot imagine how anyone could find this girl unattractive, therefore even an alien must find her attractive".

The orbitals example falls under "appear to be obvious and yet still be false". So does the FAI one ("good upbringing generally results in good citizenship, so if we educate an AGI properly, it will be friendly").

Comment author: TheOtherDave 12 September 2012 11:57:11PM 5 points [-]

Wait, what?

Presumably, any guy out there who is actually going through a reasoning process like what you describes also assumes that all women are lesbians, no? I mean, if they really can't imagine how anyone could find this girl unattractive, it follows not only that aliens are attracted to her, but that human women are as well.

But it isn't clear to me that everyone who makes this error also assumes that all women are lesbians.

Therefore it seems there's something going on besides this sort of argument from incredulity.

Powered by Reddit Powered by Reddit