Trevor_Blake comments on The Rationality Wars - Less Wrong

18 Post author: Stefan_Schubert 27 February 2014 05:08PM

You are viewing a comment permalink. View the original post to see all comments and the full post content.

Comments (41)

You are viewing a single comment's thread.

Comment author: [deleted] 27 February 2014 05:44:04PM 2 points [-]

Rationality is not equally distributed between adults and children / infants. They lack experience, education and the biologically-based capacity for rationality (ie no sense of object permanence in infants, mixed sense of conservation of matter in children). This disparity is part of how we adults can convince young people to do as we prefer (eat, wipe, not stab, etc.). So in this instance a disparity of rationality is not entirely or even mostly a bad thing. Even if it were, until we have a great deal more genetic engineering of humans and a great deal less law to prevent it we have no choice (and some would say such a choice is worse).

Comment author: David_Gerard 27 February 2014 06:00:05PM *  5 points [-]

Children are fabulously instructive in cognitive biases. It's one thing to read the list, it's another to see all of them at once, at full strength, untrammeled by collision with the real world ;-)

Comment author: Desrtopa 04 March 2014 02:22:45AM 0 points [-]

Rationality is not equally distributed between adults and children / infants. They lack experience, education and the biologically-based capacity for rationality (ie no sense of object permanence in infants, mixed sense of conservation of matter in children). This disparity is part of how we adults can convince young people to do as we prefer (eat, wipe, not stab, etc.). So in this instance a disparity of rationality is not entirely or even mostly a bad thing.

But isn't the desirability of adults being able to convince children to do as they prefer a consequence of their lesser rationality? After all, if children knew as well as adults, there would be no reason not to let them make their own decisions.