440 euros is almost the same amount as direct student benefits were in 2007, though that's not taking into account the fact that most students also have access to subsidized housing which helps substantially. On the other hand, the proposed UBI model would have maintained as separate systems the current Finnish system of "housing benefits" (which pays a part of your rent if you're low-income, exact amount depending on the city so as to take into account varying price levels around the country) as well as "income support", which is supposed to be a last-resort aid that pays for your expenses if you can show that you have reasonable needs that you just can't meet in any other way. So we might be able to say that in total, the effective total support paid to someone on basic income would have been roughly comparable to that paid to a student in 2007.
Some students manage to live on that whereas some need to take part-time jobs to supplement it, which seems to be roughly the right level to aim for - doable if you're really frugal about your expenses, but low enough that it will still encourage you to find work regardless. Might need to increase child benefits a bit in order to ensure that it's doable even if you're having a family, though.
The Greens' proposed UBI would have replaced "all welfare's minimum benefits", so other benefits that currently pay out about the same amount. That would include student benefits and the very lowest level of unemployment benefit (which you AFAIK get if your former job paid you hardly anything, basically), but it wouldn't replace e.g. higher levels of unemployment benefits.
Thanks, that's interesting and comprehensive.
Housing benefits are an alternative to the idea discussed here; i.e. subsidizing particular low-cost, low-standard flats. However, the problem with housing benefits is that you tend to get more of them if you have higher rent, and thus you in effect reward people with more expensive tastes, which leads to a general increase of housing consumption. My proposal is intended to have the exact opposite consequence.
I'm not that adverse to the UBI but there is something counter-intuitive about the idea that rich people...
Previous Open Thread
You know the drill - If it's worth saying, but not worth its own post (even in Discussion), then it goes here.
Notes for future OT posters:
1. Please add the 'open_thread' tag.
2. Check if there is an active Open Thread before posting a new one.
3. Open Threads should start on Monday, and end on Sunday.
4. Open Threads should be posted in Discussion, and not Main.