Mr Eliezer, I think you've missed a few points here. However, I've probably missed more. I apologise for errors in advance.
To start with, I speculate than any system of decision making consistently gives the wrong results on a specific problem. The whole point of decision theory is finding principles which usually end up with a better result. As such, you can always formulate a situation in which it gives the wrong answer: maybe one of the facts you thought you knew was incorrect, and led you astray. (At the very least, Omega may decide to reward only those who have never heard of a particular brand of decision theory.)
Mr Eliezer, I think you've missed a few points here. However, I've probably missed more. I apologise for errors in advance.
It's like with file... (read more)