LESSWRONG
LW

Comment Permalink
Sune10

How did this happen?! I guess not by rationalists directly trying to influence the pope? But I’m curious to know the process leading up to this.

Reply
Dirichlet-to-Neumann10

The pope has advisors. Some may even be young !

The Catholic Church has a long intellectual tradition even if it's very different from the one on lesswrong, and it has always been wary of potential misuses of new technologies. So nothing really surprising here for those who are used to Vatican-speak.

Reply
See in context
by corruptedCatapillar
1 min read
4

15

This is a linkpost for https://www.vatican.va/content/francesco/en/messages/peace/documents/20231208-messaggio-57giornatamondiale-pace2024.html

Main sections (taken from the article):

  1. The progress of science and technology as a path to peace
  2. The future of artificial intelligence: between promise and risk
  3. The technology of the future: machines that “learn” by themselves
  4. The sense of limit in the technocratic paradigm
  5. Burning issues for ethics
  6. Shall we turn swords into ploughshares?
  7. Challenges for education
  8. Challenges for the development of international law
AIWorld Optimization
Personal Blog

15

Pope Francis shares thoughts on responsible AI development
New Comment
4 comments, sorted by
top scoring
Click to highlight new comments since:
[-]the gears to ascension60

I'm surprised how pleased I am by this. From the space of possible performative signals the vatican could give, this is a good one to see. While unavoidably performative I hope it can be of use for those who already see the vatican as a reliable moral guide - as someone who does not, I find very little in this document to disagree with. I wonder if it might be too vague to have a high impact, but in terms of getting a stance out there I imagine this might be useful in communicating with some circles.

Reply
[-]Dirichlet-to-Neumann80

Speaking as a Catholic, this won't have much impact but mostly because the Catholic Church as a whole is already extremely wary about AI. It's good that it is explicitly written at the highest level though (note that what you feel is vague is just Vatican-speak).

However there is still no understanding about how powerful new AI models will be. In particular Catholics in general are skeptical about the possibility of AGI (mainly for philosophical/theological reasons). Their concerns will side more with AI-ethic rather than AI-alignment, but they will be natural allies for any "pause" or "slow-down" movement.

Reply
[-]Sune10

How did this happen?! I guess not by rationalists directly trying to influence the pope? But I’m curious to know the process leading up to this.

Reply
[-]Dirichlet-to-Neumann10

The pope has advisors. Some may even be young !

The Catholic Church has a long intellectual tradition even if it's very different from the one on lesswrong, and it has always been wary of potential misuses of new technologies. So nothing really surprising here for those who are used to Vatican-speak.

Reply
Moderation Log
More from corruptedCatapillar
View more
Curated and popular this week
4Comments