[Note to readers: The Jupyter notebook version of this post is here]

Previously: https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/fKTqwbGAwPNm6fyEH/an-apprentice-experiment-in-python-programming-part-3

Python Objects in Memory (from comments)

In the previous post, purge commented:

Due to Python's style of reference passing, most of these print statements will show matching id values even if you use any kind of object, not just True/False. Try to predict the output here, then run it to check:
def compare(x, y):
      print(x == y, id(x) == id(y), x is y)
a = {"0": "1"}
b = {"0": "1"}
print(a == b, id(a) == id(b), a is b)
compare(a, b)
c = a
d = a
print(c == d, id(c) == id(d), c is d)
compare(c, d)

When I was coming up with an answer to this question, I got stuck on what the operator is did. I only had a vague sense of how to use it—I knew comparison with None was done via is but didn't know why—so I had to look up what is actually did.

Identity comparisons
The operators "is" and "is not" test for an object’s identity: "x is y" is true if and only if x and y are the same object. An Object’s identity is determined using the "id()" function. "x is not y" yields the inverse truth value.

Here's the doc for id():

id(obj, /) Return the identity of an object. This is guaranteed to be unique among simultaneously existing objects. (CPython uses the object's memory address.)

Then I understood that is would literally check if two objects are the same object. So in the above example we'd get True False False from print(a == b, id(a) == id(b), a is b) and True True True from print(c == d, id(c) == id(d), c is d).

Object Storage in Memory

Speaking of checking if two objects being the same object stored in the same location in memory, gilch made more comments about object storage models (paraphrased):

Compared to C/C++, Python has a more consistent object storage model: everything is an object, only references to objects are stored on the stack, pointing to the actual objects stored in the heap. This means that Python objects are scattered all over the place. One important aspect of CPU optimization is caching contiguous blocks of memory in CPU caches, but Python's model cause cache-miss to be high since two objects adjacent to each other in memory are likely unrelated. This performance degradation is the price for Python's simple memory model.

For computing tasks that have high requir...

An Apprentice Experiment in Python Programming

An Apprentice Experiment in Python Programming